Archive for the 'Privacy' Category

Privacy Breach … While Jogging Down a Public Path?

By Richard Stobbe

An online video shows someone jogging on a public pathway during a 2-second clip. Let me get this straight… does this constitute a breach of privacy rights? According to an Ontario court, the answer is yes.

This is a scenario that is likely repeated every year across the country in a variety of industries. In this case, a real estate developer engaged a video developer to produce a sales video for a residential condominium project. To capture the “lifestyle” of the neighbourhood, the video developer shot footage of local shops, bicycling paths, jogging trails, and other local amenities. In the course of this project, the plaintiff – a jogger – was caught on video, and after editing, a 2-second clip of the plaintiff was included in the final 2-minute promotional video.

Like all video, this one was posted to YouTube, where it lived for 1 week, before being taken down in response to the plaintiff’s complaints.

In Vanderveen v Waterbridge Media Inc., 2017 CanLII 77435 (ON SCSM), the court considered the claim that this clip of the jogger constituted a violation of privacy rights and appropriation of personality rights.   In the analysis, the court considered the tort of “intrusion upon seclusion”, which was designed to provide a remedy for conduct that intrudes upon private affairs where the invasion of privacy is considered “highly offensive”.

The court in this case decided that a 2-second video clip of someone jogging on a public pathway does constitute a “highly offensive” invasion of a person’s private affairs. The plaintiff was awarded $4,000 for the breach of privacy rights and $100 for the appropriation of personality.

Some points to consider:

  • It is unclear why the court did not spend more time considering the issue of “reasonable expectation of privacy”. A number of court decisions have looked at this issue as it relates to video or photography on public beaches, public schools and other public places. This is not a new issue in privacy law, but it appears to have been given short shrift in this decision.
  • The impact of this decision must be put into context: it is an Ontario small claims court decision, so it won’t be binding on other courts. However, it may be referred to in other cases of this type. The decision is unlikely to be appealed considering the amounts at issue, so we probably won’t see a review of the analysis at a higher level of court.
  • Consider the implications of this approach to privacy and personality rights in light of the use of drone footage in making promotional videos – something that is becoming more common as costs lower and access to this technology increases.
  • When entering into contracts for any promotional or marketing collateral – website content, images, video footage, film, advertisements, print materials – both sides should review the terms to confirm who bears the risk of addressing complaints such as this one, and who bears the responsibility for obtaining consents or releases from recognizable individuals who appear in the media content.

 

For advice regarding privacy rights, personality rights, drone law, and video development contracts, contact Field Law.

Calgary – 10:00 MST

No comments

Another Canadian Decision Reaches Outside Canada

By Richard Stobbe

This fascinating Ontario case deals with an Alberta-based individual who complained of certain material that was re-published on the website Globe24h.com based in Romania. The server that hosted the website was located in Romania. The material in question was essentially a re-publication of certain publicly available Canadian court and tribunal decisions.

The Alberta individual complained that this conduct – the re-publication of a Canadian tribunal decision on a foreign server – was a breach of his privacy rights since he was named personally in this tribunal decision.

So, let’s get this straight, this is a privacy-based complaint relating to republication in public of a publicly available decision?

Yes, you heard that right. This Romanian site scraped decisions from Canadian court and tribunal websites (information that was already online) and made this content searchable on the internet (making it …available online).

This is an interesting decision, and we’ll just review two elements:

The first issue was whether Canadian privacy laws (such as PIPEDA ) have extraterritorial application to Globe24h.com as a foreign-based organization.  On this point, the Ontario court, citing a range of past decisions (including the Google v. Equustek decision which is currently being appealed to the Supreme Court of Canada) said:

“In this case, the location of the website operator and host server is Romania. However, when an organization’s activities take place exclusively through a website, the physical location of the website operator or host server is not determinative because telecommunications occurboth here and there”: Libman v The Queen, 1985 CanLII 51 (SCC), [1985] 2 SCR 178 at p 208 [Emphasis added]

Secondly, the Ontario court reviewed whether the Romanian business was engaged in “commercial activities” (since that is an element of PIPEDA) . The court noted the Romanian site  “was seeking payment for the removal of the personal information from the website. The fees solicited for doingdoing so varied widely. Moreover, if payment was made with respect to removal of one version of the decision, additional payments could be demanded for removal of other versions of the same information. This included, for example, the translation of the same decision in a Federal Court proceeding or earlier rulings in the same case.”

The Romanian site made a business out of removing data from this content, but the court’s conclusion that “The evidence leads to the conclusion that the respondent was running a profit-making scheme to exploit the online publication of Canadian court and tribunal decisions containing personal information.” [Emphasis added] – in a general sense, that statement could just as easily apply to Google or any of the commercial legal databases which are marketed to lawyers.

The court concluded that it could take jurisdiction over the Romanian website, and ordered the foreign party to take-down the offending content.

This decision represent another reach by a Canadian court to takedown content that has implications outside the borders of Canada.  From the context, it is likely that this decision is going to stand, since the respondent did not contest this lawsuit. The issue of extra-terrtorial reach of Canadian courts in the internet context is going to be overtaken by the pending Supreme Court decision in Equustek. Stay tuned.

 

Calgary – 07:00 MT

 

 

No comments

Dear CASL: When can I rely on “implied consent”?

.

By Richard Stobbe

Canada’s Anti-Spam Legislation (CASL) is overly complex and notoriously difficult to interpret – heck, even lawyers start to see double when they read the official title of the law (An Act to promote the efficiency and adaptability of the Canadian economy by regulating certain activities that discourage reliance on electronic means of carrying out commercial activities, and to amend the Canadian Radio-television and Telecommunications Commission Act, the Competition Act, the Personal Information Protection and Electronic Documents Act and the Telecommunications Act).

The concept of implied consent (as opposed to express consent) is built into the law, and the trick is to interpret when, exactly, a company can rely on implied consent to send commercial electronic messages (CEMs). There are a number of different types of implied consent, including a pre-existing business or non-business relationship, and the so-called “conspicuous publication exemption”.

One recent administrative decision (Compliance and Enforcement Decision CRTC 2016-428 re: Blackstone Learning Corp.) focused on “conspicuous publication” under Section 10(9) of the Act. A company may rely on implied consent to send CEMs where there is:

  1. conspicuous publication of the email address in question,
  2. the email address is not accompanied by a statement that the person does not wish to receive unsolicited commercial electronic messages at the electronic address; and
  3. the message is relevant to the person’s business, role, functions, or duties in a business or official capacity.

In this case, Blackstone Learning sent about 380,000 emails to government employees during 9 separate ad campaigns over a 3 month period in 2014. The case against Blackstone by the CRTC did not dwell on the evidence – in fact, Blackstone admitted the essential facts. Rather, this case focused on the defense raised by Blackstone. The company pointed to the “conspicuous publication exemption” and argued that it could rely on implied consent for the CEMs since the email addresses of the government employees were all conspicuously published online.

However, the company provided very little support for this assertion, and it did not provide back-up related to the other two elements of the defense; namely, that the email addresses were not accompanied by a “no spam” statement, and that the CEMs were relevant to the role or business of the recipients. The CRTC’s decision provides some guidance on implied consent and “conspicuous publication”:

  • The CRTC observed that “The conspicuous publication exemption and the requirements thereof set out in paragraph 10(9)(b) of the Act set a higher standard than the simple public availability of electronic addresses.” In other words, finding an email address online is not enough.
  • First, the exemption only applies if the email recipient publishes the email address or authorizes someone else to publish it. Let’s take the example of a sales rep who might publish his or her email, and also authorize a reseller or distributor to publish the email address. However, the CRTC notes if a third party were to collect and sell a list of such addresses on its own then “this would not create implied consent on its own, because in that instance neither the account holder nor the message recipient would be publishing the address, or be causing it to be published.”
  • The decision does not provide a lot of context around the relevance factor, or how that should be interpreted. CRTC guidance provides some obvious examples – an email advertising how to be an administrative assistant is not relevant to a CEO.  In this case, Blackstone was advertising courses related to technical writing, grammar and stress management. Arguably, these topics might be relevant to a broad range of people within the government.
  • Note that the onus of proving consent, including all the elements of the “conspicuous publication exception”, rests with the person relying on it. The CRTC is not going to do you any favours here. Make sure you have accurate and complete records to show why this exemption is available.
  • Essentially, the email address must “be published in such a manner that it is reasonable to infer consent to receive the type of message sent, in the circumstances.” Those fact-sepecific circumstances, of course, will ultimately be decided by the CRTC.
  • Lastly, the company’s efforts at compliance may factor into the ultimate penalty. Initially, the CRTC assessed an administrative monetary penalty (AMP) of $640,000 against Blackstone. The decision noted that Blackstone’s correspondence with the Department of Industry showed the “potential for self-correction” even if Blackstone’s compliance efforts were “not particularly robust”. These compliance efforts, among other factors, convinced the commission to reduce the AMP to $50,000.

As always, when it comes to CEMs, an ounce of CASL prevention is worth a pound of AMPs. Get advice from professionals about CASL compliance.

See our CASL archive for more background.

Calgary 07:00 MST

No comments

Online Defamation & Libel: The Trump Effect

By Richard Stobbe

It’s not often that our little blog intersects with such titanic struggles as the U.S. presidential race – and by using the term “titanic” I certainly don’t mean to suggest that anything disastrous is in the future.

After the New York Times published personal allegations of sexual assault against presidential candidate Donald Trump, the candidate’s lawyers promptly fired a shot across the bow, threatening legal action for libel and demanding that the article be removed from the Times’s website. Last week, the lawyer for the New York Times responded to lawyers for Mr.  Trump with a succinct defense of their publication of the article, arguing “We did what the law allows: We published newsworthy information about a subject of deep public concern.”

If this had happened in Canada, the law would almost certainly favour the position taken by the Times. In Quan v. Cusson, [2009] 3 SCR 712, the Supreme Court of Canada confirmed the defense of “responsible communication on matters of public interest” permitting journalists to report on matters of public interest. That case, interestingly, dealt with an Ontario police officer who attended in New York City shortly after the events of September 11, 2001 in order to assist with the search and rescue effort at Ground Zero. The officer sued for defamation after a newspaper published articles alleging that he had misrepresented himself to the New York authorities and possibly interfered with the rescue operation. As noted by the CBA this defense of responsible journalism applies if:

  • the news was urgent, serious, and of public importance,
  • the journalist used reliable sources, and
  • the journalist tried to get and report the other side of the story.

 

Calgary – 07:00 MST

No comments

Liability of Cloud-Based Service Provider For Data Breach

By Richard Stobbe

Silverpop Systems provides digital marketing services through a cloud-based tool called ‘Engage’. Leading Market Technologies, Inc. (“LMT”) engaged Silverpop through a service agreement and during the course of that agreement LMT uploaded digital advertising content and recipient e-mail addresses to the Engage system.  A trove of nearly half a million e-mail addresses, provided by LMT, was stored on the Engage online system. In November 2010, Silverpop’s system was hacked, putting LMT’s email list at risk. Silverpop notified LMT of the data breach.  After LMT refused to pay for further service, Silverpop suspended the agreement.

Litigation commenced in 2012, with LMT claiming damages for breach of contract and negligence based on Silverpop’s failure to keep the email list secure. Should the service provider be liable? Silverpop argued that it was engaged to provide access to its online system, not specifically to keep data secure. Thus there was no breach of its obligations under the agreement. And anyway, if LMT suffered any damages, they were indirect or consequential and consequential such damages were excluded under the terms of the agreement. LMT countered that, in fact, the agreement quite clearly contained a confidentiality clause, and that the damages suffered by LMT were direct damages, not indirect consequential damages.

The US Federal Circuit Court of Appeals in Silverpop Systems Inc. v. Leading Market Technologies Inc. sided with Silverpop:

  • “Here, the parties’ agreement was not one for the safeguarding of the LMT List. Rather, the parties contracted for the providing of e-mail marketing services. While it was necessary for LMT to provide a list of intended recipients (represented as e-mail addresses on the LMT List) to ensure that the service Silverpop provided (targeted e-mail marketing) was carried out, the safe storage of the list was not the purpose of the agreement between the parties.” (Emphasis added)

The court was careful to review both the limit of liability clause (which provided an overall cap on liability to 12 months fees), and the exclusion clause (which barred recovery for indirect or consequential damages). The overall limit of liability had an exception: the cap did not apply to a breach of the confidentiality obligation. However, this exception did not impact the scope of the limit on indirect or consequential damages.  Since the court decided that the claimed breach did not result from a failure of performance, and the consequential damages clause applied to LMT’s alleged loss. As a result, LMT’s claims were dismissed.

Lessons for business?

  • Those limitation of liability and exclusion clauses are often considered “boilerplate”. But they really do make a difference in the event of a claim. Ensure you have experienced counsel providing advice when negotiating these clauses, from either the customer or service provider perspective.

 

Calgary – 07:00 MST

No comments

CASL Enforcement (Part 1)

.
By Richard Stobbe

Since July 1, 2014, Canada’s Anti-Spam Law (or CASL) has been in effect, and the software-related rules have been in force since January 15, 2015.

With the benefit of hindsight, we can see a few patterns emerge from the efforts by the enforcement trifecta: the Privacy Commissioner of Canada, the CRTC and the Competition Bureau. (For background, see our earlier posts) What follows is a round-up of some of the most interesting and instructive enforcement actions:

  • March 2015 – A notice of violation was issued by the Competition Bureau to 3510395 Canada Inc. (dba Compu.Finder) with an accompanying administrative monetary penalty of $1,100,000 for sending commercial electronic messages without the consent and for commercial electronic messages which contained an ineffective unsubscribe mechanism in violation of CASL.
  • March 2015 – A penalty of $48,000 was levied against Plentyoffish Media Inc. as part of an undertaking concerning an alleged CASL violation related to an unsubscribe mechanism that was not set out “clearly and prominently” and was not able to be “readily performed”.
  • March 2015 – The Competition Bureau commenced action against Avis Budget Group Inc. for deceptive marketing practices, seeking $30 million in administrative monetary penalties from the companies, and refunds for consumers. The Bureau took action under CASL since Avis and Budget used electronic messages to disseminate the alleged false or misleading representations.
  • June 2015 – Porter Airlines Inc. paid $150,000 as part of an undertaking concerning certain CASL violations that were very similar to those which caught Plentyoffish. The Porter allegations related to commercial electronic messages that contained an unsubscribe mechanism that was not set out “clearly and prominently”, or that were missing an unsubscribe mechanism.
  • November 2015 – Similarly, Rogers Media paid $200,000 as part of a CASL investigation into commercial electronic messages that either contained an unsubscribe mechanism that was not able to be “readily performed”, that did not enable the person to indicate their wish to no longer receive messages or that did not provide an electronic address for the purposes of unsubscribing that was valid for a period of 60 days after the message was sent.
  • This certainly points to the more technical risks of poorly implemented unsubscribe features, rather than underlying gaps in consent. Perhaps this is because heavy enforcement action related directly to consent is still to come. Implied consent can be relied upon during a three-year transitional period. After that window closes, expect enforcement to focus on failures of consent.

    To put this all in perspective, consider enforcement of other laws within the CRTC mandate: in 2014 the CRTC did not issue any notices of violation of CASL, but issued 10 notices of violation related to the Unsolicited Telecommunications Rules and the National Do Not Call List (DNCL); in 2015 the CRTC issued 1 notice of violation of CASL and about 20 related to the Do Not Call List.

    Calgary – 07:00 MT

    1 comment

    Apple’s Liability for the Xcode Hack

    .

    By Richard Stobbe

    I don’t think I’m going out on a limb by speculating that someone, somewhere is preparing a class-action suit based on the recently disclosed hack of Apple’s app ecosystem.iphone6_34fl_3_color_spaced_homescreen_landing.jpg

    How did it happen? In a nutshell, hackers were able to infect a version of Apple’s Xcode software package for iOS app developers. A number of iOS developers – primarily in China, according to recent reports – downloaded this corrupted version of Xcode, then used it to compile their apps. This corrupted version was not the “official” Apple version; it was accessed from a third-party file-sharing site. Apps compiled with this version of Xcode were infected with malware known as XcodeGhost. These corrupted apps were uploaded and distributed through Apple’s Chinese App Store. In this way the XcodeGhost malware snuck past Apple’s own code review protocols and, through the wonder of app store downloads, it infected millions of iOS devices around the world.

    The malware does a number of nasty things – including fishing for a user’s iCloud password.

    This case provides a good case study for how risk is allocated in license agreements and terms of service. What do Apple’s terms say about this kind of thing? In Canada, the App Store Terms and Conditions govern a user’s contractual relationship with Apple for the use of the App Store. On the face of it, these terms disclaim liability for any “…LOSS, CORRUPTION, ATTACK, VIRUSES, INTERFERENCE, HACKING, OR OTHER SECURITY INTRUSION, AND APPLE CANADA DISCLAIMS ANY LIABILITY RELATING THERETO.”

    Apple could be expected to argue that this clause deflects liability. And if Apple is found liable, then it would seek the cover of its limitation of liability clause. In the current version of the terms, Apple claims an overall limit of liability of $50. Let’s not forget that “hundreds of millions of users” are potentially affected.

    As a preliminary step however, Apple would be expected to argue that the law of the State of California governs the contract, and Apple would be arguing that any remedy must be sought in a California court (see our post the other day: Forum Selection in Online Terms).

    Will this limit of liability and forum-selection clause hold up to the scrutiny of Canadian courts if there is a claim against Apple?

    Calgary – 07:00 MT

    No comments

    Outsourcing by Canadian Companies after the USA PATRIOT Act

    capture2.JPGBy Richard Stobbe

    Wondering about outsourcing your data to the U.S.? What follows is an update to one of our most popular posts: Outsourcing by Canadian Companies: Another Look at the USA PATRIOT Act, originally written in January 2013.

    In that post, we discussed the concern that U.S. government authorities may use the provisions of the Uniting and Strengthening America by Providing Appropriate Tools Required to Intercept and Obstruct Terrorism Act (“PATRIOT Act”) to access the personal information of Canadians where that information is stored in the United States in the context of outsourcing or cloud-computing.

    We also noted that for private sector businesses there are no specific legal prohibitions on outsourcing to the United States in light of the PATRIOT Act, provided (1) reasonable safeguards are built into the outsource contract (including confidentiality, use-restrictions, security, and provisions to meet monitoring and audit requirements), and (2) customers are notified in a clear way when their personal information will be stored or handled outside Canada. The only exceptions to this are within the public sector, as reviewed in our earlier post.

    What Has Changed and What Remains the Same

    This is a complicated area of law. Starting in June 2013, Edward Snowden’s revelations about N.S.A.’s pervasive warrantless surveillance programs triggered a broader debate about privacy, as well as the specific risks of outsourcing to U.S. companies.

    Certain provisions of the PATRIOT Act expired under a sunset clause on June 1, 2015. The U.S. Congress passed the USA FREEDOM Act on June 2, 2015 (in keeping with the American penchant for legislative acronyms, the full name is “Uniting and Strengthening America by Fulfilling Rights and Ending Eavesdropping, Dragnet-collection and Online Monitoring Act“).

    The USA FREEDOM Act restores many of the expired provisions of the PATRIOT Act through 2019. Some provisions of the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Amendments Act will expire in 2017 (including Section 702, a provision which underpins some of the N.S.A.’s bulk surveillance of online communications). Under the FREEDOM Act, certain sections of the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act of 1978 were amended in an effort to delimit the NSA’s mass data collection programs. However, the restrictions on bulk data collection don’t take effect for 6 months after the USA FREEDOM Act is enacted. There is also a carve-out to permit the government to obtain FISA orders during this 180-day period. The effect of this is unclear, but commentators have speculated that during this 6-month grace period the N.S.A. can continue bulk collection, and obtain FISA orders which are not constrained by the requirement for a “selection term”.

    Furthermore, bulk collection of phone data is not necessarily coming to an end – arguably, it is merely being delegated to the telecoms: “The Freedom Act does take the bulk collection of Americans’ telephone records out of the hands of the National Security Agency and leaves those records with the phone companies; it sets up procedures for the NSA to get access to those records when it wants to.

    The new law does introduce reforms for oversight of government surveillance. In a nod to transparency, some FISA Court opinions may become available, and technology companies will have the ability to publicly report the number of government surveillance requests or investigation inquiries they receive. Previously, companies were prohibited from reporting that such requests had been received.

    Generally, under the FREEDOM Act, indiscriminate bulk data collection is to be reformed by requiring the use of “specific selection terms”. In other words, government agencies such as the NSA must use a search term – the name of a specific person, account, address, or personal device, or any other specific identifier – to limit the scope of data collection “to the greatest extent reasonably practicable”.

    In 2004, after the initial flurry of anxiety about US government surveillance under the PATRIOT Act, the Privacy Commissioner of Canada noted: “The [PATRIOT] Act is simply one example of a law that can give the United States government or its agencies access to personal information about Canadians that has been transferred to the United States. Research done by the Office of the Privacy Commissioner and discussions with the Department of Justice suggest that the USA PATRIOT Act is not likely in the normal course of events to be used to obtain personal information held in the United States about Canadians.” (Emphasis added)

    In light of the 2013 Snowden revelations (and the 2007 Mark Klein disclosures), we now know that, in fact, the bulk collection of phone and internet data by the N.S.A. would have resulted in a lot of personal information about Canadians being collected by the N.S.A. in the United States through the N.S.A.’s PRISM, ECHELON and related surveillance programs.

    Data access by Canadian or American government authorities in the course of investigations is not new. Don’t forget that the PATRIOT Act itself was merely an amendment and expansion to a series of existing government investigation tools which were already part of U.S. law, such as the Electronic Communications Privacy Act, Computer Fraud and Abuse Act, Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act, Money Laundering Control Act and the Bank Secrecy Act. Going back even further, NSA’s cooperation and information-sharing with Canadian security agencies actually dates to the 1940s (see: the UK-USA Agreement). However, the sheer scope, breadth and depth of surveillance was new.

    The Americans are not the only ones who carry on surveillance. There are a number of Canadian laws that enable police, security agencies and government investigators to obtain access to information held in Canada in the course of an investigation. And as in the U.S., Canadian security agencies have also been caught exceeding the legal limits on their online surveillance (see X (Re), 2013 FC 1275; aff’d 2014 FCA 249, where the Federal Court and Federal Court of Appeal decided that CSIS breached the duty of candour owing to the Court in seeking and obtaining search warrants fro surveillance on Canadians outside Canada).

    Canadian police and security agencies can also obtain information held in the U.S., just as American security agencies can obtain records held in Canada through information-sharing agreements, protocols and a bilateral treaty between the United States and Canada known as the Mutual Legal Assistance Treaty (the “MLAT”). Other countries have similar investigative powers.

    While the Americans are making some modest reforms to their surveillance laws, Canadian authorities are actually expanding their reach; the Anti-terrorism Act, 2015 (Bill C-51) was passed on June 9, 2015, and is awaiting royal assent. This new law expands the information-gathering powers between CSIS, police investigators and other Canadian government agencies.

    Further, the effect of so-called “boomerang routing” means that online information flowing between a Canadian sender and Canadian recipient is still often routed through the US. (See: IXMaps.ca) Thus, even where data is not physically stored in the US, it may be caught by ongoing N.S.A. surveillance at the point the data traverses through an internet exchange point located within the United States.

    Conclusion

    As a matter of risk-assessment for Canadian companies outsourcing data to cloud-computing service providers, should you be concerned that your (or your customers’) Canadian online data will be subject to access by the U.S. government?

    1. We know that for Canadian private sector businesses there are still no legal prohibitions against outsourcing data to the United States (note that the public sector is treated differently);

    2. Best practices still dictate that (a) reasonable safeguards should be built into the outsource contract (including confidentiality, use-restrictions, security, and provisions to meet monitoring and audit requirements), and (b) customers should notified in a clear way when their personal information will be stored or handled outside Canada.

    3. There can be no doubt that surveillance practices under the (old) PATRIOT Act resulted in the mass indiscriminate collection of internet and phone data for many years (and very likely continues within the 6-month period after enactment of the FREEDOM Act). It appears very likely that Canadian data outsourced to the U.S. was subject to bulk collection by the N.S.A. Due to “boomerang routing”, it appears likely that even data stored on servers located within Canada often flows through internet exchange locations within the U.S., and therefore would be susceptible to bulk collection by the N.S.A. The USA FREEDOM Act (which is really the PATRIOT Act 2.0) does impose some mild but important reforms on the scope of N.S.A. surveillance. If bulk data and phone-record collection is actually curtailed, the ongoing risk is associated with “targeted” or “selection term” access, in situations where government security and law enforcement agencies exercise rights of accessing and monitoring online data in the course of investigations of a “specific person, account, address, or personal device” in the U.S. It is worth noting that this ongoing risk of access is similar on both sides of the Canada/U.S. border, since Canadian security and law enforcement agencies have similar powers of investigation, and the two governments can rely on MLAT requests and other information sharing protocols to share data.

    When you weigh the issues and risks associated with outsourcing Canadian data to the U.S., consider these points and seek advice from experienced IT and privacy counsel.

    Further reading: Law, Privacy and Surveillance in Canada in the Post-Snowden Era.

    Calgary – 07:00 MDT

    No comments

    Copyright Implications of a “Right to be Forgotten”? Or How to Take-Down the Internet Archive.

    By Richard Stobbe 

    They say the internet never forgets. From time to time, someone wants to challenge that dictum.

    In our earlier posts, we discussed the so-called “right to be forgotten” in connection with a Canadian trade-secret misappropriation and passing-off case and an EU privacy case. In a brief ruling in October, the Federal Court reviewed a copyright claim that fits into this same category. In Davydiuk v. Internet Archive Canada, 2014 FC 944 (CanLII), the plaintiff sought to remove certain pornographic films that were filmed and posted online years earlier. By 2009, the plaintiff had successfully pulled down the content from the original sites on which the content had been hosted. However, the plaintiff discovered that the Internet Archive’s “Wayback Machine” had crawled and retained copies of the content as part of its archive.

    If you’re not familiar with the Wayback Machine, here is the court’s description: “The ‘Wayback Machine’ is a collection of websites accessible through the websites ‘archive.org’ and ‘web.archive.org’. The collection is created by software programs known as crawlers, which surf the internet and store copies of websites, preserving them as they existed at the time they were visited. According to Internet Archive, users of the Wayback Machine can view more than 240 billion pages stored in its archive that are hosted on servers located in the United States. The Wayback Machine has six staff to keep it running and is operated from San Francisco, California at Internet Archive’s office. None of the computers used by Internet Archive are located in Canada.”

    The plaintiff used copyright claims to seek the removal of this content from the Internet Archive servers, and these efforts included DMCA notices in the US. Ultimately unsatisfied with the results, the plaintiff commenced an action in Federal Court in Canada based on copyrights. The Internet Archive disputed that Canada was the proper forum: it argued that California was more appropriate since all of the servers in question were located in the US and Internet Archive was a California entity.

    Since Internet Archive raised a doctrine known as “forum non conveniens”, it had to convince the court that the alternative forum (California) was “clearly more appropriate” than the Canadian court. It is not good enough to simply that there is an appropriate forum elsewhere, rather the party making this argument has to show that clearly the other forum is more appropriate, fairer and more efficient. The Federal Court was not convinced, and it concluded that there was a real and substantial connection to Canada. The case will remain in Canadian Federal Court. A few interesting points come out of this decision:

    1. This is not a privacy case. It turns upon copyright claims, since the plaintiff in this case had acquired the copyrights to the original content. Nevertheless, the principles in this case (to determine which court is the proper place to hear the case) could be applied to any number of situations, including privacy, copyright or personality rights.
    2. Interestingly, the fact that the plaintiff had used American DMCA notices did not, by itself, convince the court that the US was the best forum for this case.
    3. The court looked to a recent trademark decision (Homeaway.com Inc. v. Hrdlicka) to show that a trademark simply appearing on the computer screen in Canada constituted use and advertising in Canada for trademark law purposes. Here, accessing the content in Canada from servers located in the US constituted access in Canada for copyright purposes.
    4. While some factors favoured California, and some favoured Canada, the court concluded that California was not clearly more appropriate. This shows there is a first-mover advantage in commencing the action in the preferred jurisdiction.  

    Get advice on internet copyright claims by contacting our Intellectual Property & Technology Group.

    Calgary – 07:00 MST

     

    No comments

    Update: PIPA Revived

    By Richard Stobbe

    As a follow-up to our earlier post (PIPA on Death’s Door), Alberta’s Personal Information Protection Act (PIPA) has been resuscitated. The Supreme Court of Canada (SCC) has granted a six-month reprieve, to allow the Government of Alberta to pass amendments to PIPA. An amended bill was tabled in the legislature last week. The amendments attempt to strike a balance to address the constitutional issues that were the cause of the Act’s downfall in an SCC decision more than a year ago.

    Stay tuned.

    Calgary – 07:00 MST

    No comments

    Two Privacy Class Actions: Facebook and Apple (Part 2)

    Courtesy of Apple

    By Richard Stobbe

    In Part 1, we looked at the B.C. decision in Douez v. Facebook, Inc.

    Another proposed privacy class action was heard in the B.C. court a few months later: Ladas v. Apple Inc., 2014 BCSC 1821 (CanLII).

    This was a claim by a representative plaintiff, Ms. Ladas, alleging that Apple breached the customer’s right to privacy under the Privacy Act (B.C.), since iOS 4 records the location of the “iDevice” (that’s the term used by the court for any Apple-branded iOS products) by surreptitiously recording and storing locational data in unencrypted form which is “accessible to Apple”. The claim did not assert that this info was transmitted to Apple, merely that it was “accessible to Apple”. This case involved a different section of the Privacy Act (B.C.) than the one claimed in Douez.

    The Ladas claim, curiously, referred to a number of public-sector privacy laws as a basis for the class action, and the court dismissed these claims as providing no legal basis. The court did accept that there was a basis for a claim under the Privacy Act (B.C.) and similar legislation in 3 other provinces. However, the claim fell down on technical merit. It did not meet all of the requirements under the Class Proceedings Act: specifically, the court was not convinced that there was an “identifiable class” of 2 or more persons, and did not accept there were “common issues” among the proposed class members (assuming there was an identifiable class).

    Thus, the class action was not certified. It was dismissed without leave to amend the pleadings.

    Apple’s iOS software license agreement did not come into play, since the claim was dismissed on other grounds. If the claim had proceeded far enough to consider the iOS license, then it would surely have faced the same defences raised by Facebook in Douez. As the judgement noted: Apple argued that “every time a user updates the version of iOS running on the user’s iDevice, the user is prompted to decide whether the user wants to use Location Services by accepting the terms of Apple’s software licensing agreement. Apple relies on users taking such steps in its defence of the plaintiff’s claims. The legal effect of a user clicking on “consent” or “allow” or “ok” or “I agree” would be an issue on the merits in this action.”

    Any test of Apple’s license agreement will have to wait for another day.

    Calgary – 07:00 MST

    No comments

    Two Privacy Class Actions: Facebook and Apple

    By Richard Stobbe

    Two privacy class actions earlier this year have pitted technology giants Facebook Inc. and Apple Inc. against Canadian consumers who allege privacy violations. The two cases resulted in very different outcomes.

    First, the Facebook decision: In Douez v. Facebook, Inc., 2014 BCSC 953 (CanLII), the court looked at two basic questions:

    1. Do British Columbian users of social media websites run by a foreign corporation have the protection of BC’s Privacy Act, R.S.B.C. 1996, c. 373?
    2. Do the online terms of use for social media override these protections?

    The plaintiff Ms. Douez alleged that Facebook used the names and likenesses of Facebook customers for advertising through so-called “Sponsored Stories”.  The claim alleges that Facebook ran the “Sponsored Stories” program without the permission of customers, contrary to of s. 3(2) of the B.C. Privacy Act which says:

    “It is a tort, actionable without proof of damage, for a person to use the name or portrait of another for the purpose of advertising or promoting the sale of, or other trading in, property or services, unless that other, or a person entitled to consent on his or her behalf, consents to the use for that purpose.”

    Interestingly, this Act was first introduced in B.C. in 1968, even before the advent of the primitive internet in 1969 .

    Facebook argued that its Terms of Use precluded any claim in a B.C. court, due to the “Forum Selection Clause” which compels action in the State of California. The court accepted that, on its face, the Terms of Service were valid, clear and enforceable. However, the court went on to decide that the B.C. Privacy Act establishes unique claims and specific jurisdiction. The Act mandates that claims under it “must be heard and determined by the Supreme Court” in British Columbia. This convinced the court that Facebok’s Forum Selection Clause should be set aside in this case, and the claim should proceed in a B.C. court.

    The class action was certified. Facebook has appealed. Stay tuned.

    Next up, the Apple experience.

    Calgary – 07:00 MST

    No comments

    Alberta Privacy Law Update: PIPA on Death’s Door

    By Richard Stobbe

    About a year ago on November 15, 2013, Alberta’s Personal Information Protection Act (PIPA) was declared invalid on constitutional grounds. The Supreme Court of Canada (SCC), in its wisdom, deferred the effect of this order for a 1 year period, to permit the Alberta legislature to revisit and amend the legislation to bring it in line with the Constitution. The legislature has drafted legislation in the intervening period, but is not due to return to work until November 17, 2014, two days after the court’s declaration of invalidity takes effect.

    The Alberta government has filed a motion asking the SCC to extend the suspension period, to provide more time to address the issue, but an overhaul of PIPA is not an easy or quick task. Stay tuned.

    Calgary – 07:00 MDT

    No comments

    An American Attorney in Canada (Part 2: Anti-Spam)

    By Richard Stobbe

    Canada and the USA. We enjoy the world’s longest undefended border… a border that unfortunately does not screen spam.

    If you are an American attorney with US clients doing business in Canada, then you should be aware of a few things, like our lack of imaginative legislative acronyms, such as the CAN-SPAM Act (from Controlling the Assault of Non-Solicited Pornography And Marketing) (…or while we’re at, who can forget the Preventing Real Online Threats to Economic Creativity and Theft of Intellectual Property (PROTECT-IP) Act, or the Enforcing and Protecting American Rights Against Sites Intent on Theft and Exploitation (E-PARASITE) Act).

    Secondly, you should be aware that Canada’s incoming anti-spam law, known unimaginatively as CASL (Canada’s Anti-Spam Law) is coming into force next week, on July 1, 2014. Here are some pointers for US counsel:

    • Remember, an organization’s compliance with CAN-SPAM does not necessarily mean compliance with CASL. This is because of a number of important points of departure between the two laws. Canada’s law has been described as among the strictest internationally.
    • CASL broadly covers all “commercial electronic messages” and is not restricted to email, as is the case with CAN-SPAM. Thus, CASL is broad enough to capture text messages, social media messaging and other forms of electronic messages.
    • CAN-SPAM permits a “negative option” approach to consent, in which toggle consent boxes can be pre-clicked and the user has the ability to opt out by “un-clicking”. CASL prohibits such an approach and requires express consent with an opt-in mechanism.
    • Statutory penalties under CASL are more severe (up to $10 million for organizations, and up to $1 million for individuals), and the law also establishes a broader private right of civil action (which will come into effect in the future).
    • Lastly, CASL does provide for personal liability for directors and officers.

    For more information on the application of this law to American businesses, contact Field Law.

    Calgary – 07:00 MST

    No comments

    Supreme Court of Canada on Internet Privacy

    By Richard Stobbe

    The Supreme Court puts it mildly in its opening line: “The Internet raises a host of new and challenging questions about privacy.”

    One of those questions is whether an IP address can be considered personal information. An internet protocol (IP) address is the unique numeric identifier of a particular computer and, in a wider sense, can be any node or point in the internet generally. In the recent case of R. v. Spencer, 2014 SCC 43, the Supreme Court of Canada (SCC) considered whether there is a reasonable expectation of privacy in ISP subscriber information including IP address information.

    In this case, police identified the IP address of a computer that someone had been using to access child pornography.  Police approached the ISP and obtained the subscriber information associated with that IP address. At this point, no warrant was issued. This led them to the accused  and a warrant was issued for a search of his residence. The accused was charged and convicted. The SCC indicated that in this case, there was a reasonable expectation of privacy in the subscriber information, including the IP address.

    Since the search of the subscriber info was obtained without a warrant, the search violated the Charter. While a warrant was eventually issued for a search of the accused’s residence, that warrant could not have been obtained without the original (warrantless, unconstitutional) search of the ISP subscriber information. Since the original search was unconstitutional, it follows that the search of the residence was also unconstitutional. This all leads to the exclusion of the evidence found at the residence.

    Nevertheless, the SCC said that, even in light of all of the above points, the “police conduct in this case would not tend to bring the administration of justice into disrepute.”  The court concluded, in essence, that excluding the evidence would be worse than allowing that unconstitutional search. The admission of the evidence was therefore upheld.

    A few key points to note:

    • Terms of Use and Privacy Policies are carefully reviewed and taken into account by the court in these cases.
    • In this case Shaw was the ISP. Shaw’s Privacy Policy said that “Shaw may disclose Customer’s Personal Information to: . . . a third party or parties, where the Customer has given Shaw Consent to such disclosure or if disclosure is required by law…”  The initial warrantless search by the police was not “required by law” (in the sense that it was merely a request and police had no way to legally compel compliance). This contributed to the court’s conclusion that there was a reasonable expectation of privacy on the part of the accused.
    • This contrasts with the decision by the Ontario Court of Appeal in R. v. Ward 2012 ONCA 660, where the court held that the provisions of PIPEDA were a factor which weighed against finding a reasonable expectation of privacy in subscriber information. That was another child pornography case. In that case, the ISP was Bell, whose terms said “[Bell Sympatico will] offer full co-operation with law enforcement agencies in connection with any investigation arising from a breach of this [Acceptable Use Policy].” There was no reference to disclosures “required” by law.  In that case, the accused has a subjective expectation of privacy, but that expectation was not objectively reasonable in light of his criminal activities.
    • Consider reviewing your privacy policies and your organization’s ability to disclose subscriber information in light of these decisions.

    Calgary – 07:00 MST

    No comments

    The Transitional Period & Implied Consent Under CASL

    By Richard Stobbe

    If the term “CASL compliance” is giving you a nervous twitch, you’re not alone. Many small and medium-sized businesses in Canada are scrambling to prepare for Canada’s Anti-Spam Law (CASL), whose official title says it all – especially the part about “efficiency and adaptability” (take a deep breath before you read “An Act to promote the efficiency and adaptability of the Canadian economy by regulating certain activities that discourage reliance on electronic means of carrying out commercial activities, and to amend the Canadian Radio-television and Telecommunications Commission Act, the Competition Act, the Personal Information Protection and Electronic Documents Act and the Telecommunications Act“).

    Two weeks from today, on July 1st, the first stage of the new law will come into force. The implied consent provisions in Section 66 create a transitional period.

    For a period of three years after July 1, 2014, consent is implied for all “commercial electronic messages” (CEMs) if the sender and the recipient have a pre‐existing business or non-business relationship and that relationship previously included the exchange of CEMs.  Consent can be withdrawn by the recipient at any time during that three‐year period. Note that “commercial electronic messages”, “existing business relationship” and “existing non-business relationship” all have special definitions in the legislation.

    While this transitional period only lasts for 36 months, it allows a sender of CEMs to rely on prior relationships that reach back in time. The regular implied consent provisions only permit a sender to rely on a two-year window – in other words, implied consent depends on an existing relationship during the two-year period before the CEM is sent (or only 6-months in some cases).

    In recent information sessions, the CRTC has indicated that the Section 66 transition provisions do not impose those two-year or 6-month rules: “So what Section 66 does is during that transition period of three years, the definitions of existing business relationship and existing non-business relationship are not subject to the limitation period, which are six months and two years that would otherwise be applicable. So in theory, if you meet the definition of existing business relationship or existing non-business relationship and there’s the communication of CEMs between the individuals, you could go back 25 years in theory.” [Link to transcript.]

    Don’t think the transitional period lets you off the hook. Every organization should be preparing for CASL for a July 1st start date. If you need assistance on reviewing the scope of your obligations, how the law applies, and how the transitional provisions might apply to your organization, contact us.

    Calgary – 07:00 MST

    No comments

    A “Right to be Forgotten” in Canada?

    By Richard Stobbe

    A recent EU decision by the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) has generated a lot of press since it involves a high profile company – Google – and a tantalizing concept of a “right to be forgotten”. The story stems from the efforts by a Spanish man to compel Google to remove search results that referred to the man’s prior financial history – in fact the references were to bankruptcy-related notices published by a Spanish newspaper years earlier. The online newspaper publication remains in place, but the CJEU’s decision touches on the indexing and display of the results in a Google search, which refer back to that online newspaper publication.

    So what does this mean for Canada?

    There has, as far as I am aware, no equivalent privacy-related decision relating to removal of search results by search engines in Canada. However, there are analogous rights in Canada for individuals to compel an organization to correct or delete personal information. And that would apply to the organization that has “collected, used or disclosed” the personal information.

    In Canada, PIPEDA does contemplate the correction of personal information, the withdrawal of consent, and the deletion of personal information that has been collected. Those provisions still require the individual to make a request or a complaint in order to get a remedy.

    In that sense the EU organization (in the EU context) in Google’s position then has to decide on the merits of that request or complaint, so the “right” may be subject to the interpretation of these subjective questions by a Google employee, considering all the different criteria that the EU decision has listed.

    In Canada (in the PIPEDA context), the organization does not have to make the same kinds of assessments or value judgements – the question is simply whether the individual is withdrawing consent, or correcting information.

    In the EU, the organization has to decide if “in all the circumstances” the info appears to be “inadequate, irrelevant or no longer relevant, or excessive” which requires the exercise of a lot more judgement. And more scope for disagreement.

    How this is handled by Google, and how it may influence Canadian decisions on requests for removal of personal information, remains to be seen.

    Calgary – 07:00 MST

    1 comment

    Incoming Anti-Spam Software Regulations

    Most Canadian businesses will have heard of the incoming Canadian Anti-Spam Law (referred to as CASL, which joins the Canadian pantheon of legislative acronyms like PIPEDA and PIPA). The consent requirements for sending commercial electronic messages (CEMs) is covered elsewhere (See here, and see this upcoming event on March 18 and 20, 2014). Those requirements come into effect July 1, 2014.

    The software-related regulations are getting less press. Why? Possibly because CASL is being implemented in phases, and the software-related rules are not expected to be in full force until January 15, 2015. And possibly because the software-related regs are complicated and at times confusing.

    This element of CASL is designed to control surreptitious installation of software, particularly “invasive software”. Generally, express, clear consent is required. Installation of invasive software imposes additional requirements. Implied consent (or “deemed express consent”) may be relied upon in other cases:

    • cookies, HTML code, Java scripts;
    • upgrades for telecom network security;
    • “reasonable” installs – where it is reasonable to expect that the user would consent.

    Software vendors should take note of these incoming obligations, to assess and plan for any updates that will be required for CASL compliance. Get advice on how these regulations apply to your software products.

    Calgary – 07:00 MST

    No comments

    Google’s Breach of Canadian Privacy Rules

    In a recent decision released by the Canadian Privacy Commissioner (PIPEDA Report of Findings #2014-001), the commissioner investigated a complaint that Google pitched ads to an individual based on medical information that he disclosed while surfing various health-related websites. The commissioner’s office took the position that “meaningful consent” is required for the delivery of this kind of targeted advertising. Implied consent might be acceptable in certain circumstances, where the information is limited to “non-sensitive information (which would avoid medical, financial or health information).

    In this case, the individual who initiated the complaint was using Google to search for information related to a medical device used to treat a specific medical condition. Google used this sensitive personal health information (as the commissioner described it, the “online activities and viewing history of health related websites”) to target ads to that individual. When Google relied on implied consent for the use of this sensitive personal health information, it contravened Principles 4.3 and 4.3.6 of the Act. Express consent is required for use of this kind of sensitive personal information.

    Calgary – 07:00 MST

    No comments

    Alberta Privacy Law Update: PIPA Declared Invalid

    In the case of Alberta (Information and Privacy Commissioner) v. United Food and Commercial Workers, Local 401, 2013 SCC 62, released last Friday, the Supreme Court of Canada has declared the Alberta Personal Information Protection Act (PIPA) invalid in its entirety.

    This case pits constitutional rights against privacy rights. The court reviewed a claim of privacy rights infringement arising from a long strike during which both the Union and the employer recorded and photographed individuals crossing the picketline. Some of those who were photographed crossing the picketline filed privacy complaints when the Union posted those pictures online.

    As a consent-based privacy law, PIPA establishes a general requirement to obtain consent for any collection, use or disclosure of personal information. According to the court: “The central issue is whether PIPA achieves a constitutionally acceptable balance between the interests of individuals in controlling the collection, use and disclosure of their personal information and a union’s freedom of expression. PIPA does not include any mechanisms by which a union’s constitutional right to freedom of expression may be balanced with the interests protected by the legislation.” Thus, in the end, the entire Act has been declared constitutionally invalid, and in a unique way of avoiding a gap in the law, the court’s declaration has been suspended for 1 year, to allow the Alberta legislature to fix the law.

    Stay tuned.

    Calgary – 07:00 MST

    No comments

    Next Page »

    psy 450 rel 133 week 4 sci 241 week one assignment research paper help thesis statement do homework help students learn how to write a nursing philosophy paper where can i buy essays yahoo answers help on descriptive essay doctorate degree by thesis only college application essay pay 10 steps download dissertation writing services malaysia doctoral dissertation lit review james madison essay dissertation writing services malaysia south africa writing an essay for college application structure dissertation comment faire un plan harvard dissertation online buy ventolin online australia where can you buy motilium where can i buy aciclovir tablets buy tenormin no prescription revia online where to order antabuse revia hair color reviews buy ventolin online usa is minocycline cheaper than doxycycline can i buy doxycycline in bali buy bactrim buy doxycycline mexico buy premarin australia prescription assistance for premarin premarin canadian pharmacy acc 561 ideal manufacturing company acc 547 week 5 problem set acct 211 liberty university acc 492 final exam bsa 375 week 5 learning team bio 101 nassau community college bis 220 week 3 team assignment acct 212 course project 2 mcdonough acct 346 final exam acc 455 corporate taxation apol 104 flashcards bshs 352 week 3 bis 220 information systems proposal acc 541 auditing a publicly traded company bibl 104 db forum 1 ashford math 221 week 4 acc 340 navy apol 104 week 8 acc 557 chapter 7 quiz acc 410 final exam ryerson bsa 385 week 3 individual assignment acc 401 chapter 11 acc 400 week 5 acc 544 justification for an internal control system cheap prednisolone tablets buy cheap metformin online buy metformin sr purchase of prednisolone lisinopril hydrochlorothiazide buy online order prednisone for dogs buy lisinopril hydrochlorothiazide can you order prednisone online can you buy metformin over the counter buy lisinopril tablets buy prednisolone uk how to buy metformin online order prednisone for pets buy prednisolone 5mg buy prednisone for dogs online cheap maxalt no perscription requip 2mg purchase finasteride no scams buy genuine requip ordering prednisone online buy 1 mg finpecia uk where can i buy lisinopril online without a prescription how to order orlistat premarin without doctor prescription wholesale orlistat orlistat online no prescriptions required from the us where can i purchase premarin no rx cheapest place to buy metformin buy finasteride no visa online without rx buy premarin us maxalt without a perscription shipped overnight express maxalt without a dr no presciption finasteride where to buy metformin online buy prednisone over the counter order cytotec online no prescription pharma life prescription lisinopril oi 361 definitions paper math 156 week 3 venn diagram buy ventolin online ireland how to buy motilium domperidone premarin to get period can you buy atarax over the counter where to buy antabuse in uk premarin for cheap premarin online kaufen price of revia order avodart canada buy betta ampicillin cost of premarin cream without insurance cheap fluoxetine online buy premarin canada buy zovirax ointment 5 buy erythromycin topical gel buy furosemide 100 mg sci 241 human digestion checkpoint psy 390 operant conditioning paper qnt/351 quantitative analysis for business final exam buy cytotec 200 mcg cheap without perscription pharmacy where you can purchasr prednisone 20 mg without prescription cytotec 200 mcg order where can i buy premarin 0.625 mg over the counter finpecia 1 mg purchase without perscripotion buy real cytotec 200 mcg purchace lisinopril 5 mg online purchasing prednisone 20 mg generic metformin 500 mg without prescription canada lisinopril 5 mg buy online generic prednisone 20 mg online problems with buying premarin 0.625 mg without rx maxalt 5 mg generic no prescription edl 510 comp 230 week 5 quiz comp 230 week 7 quiz eng 101 2nd assignment cja 204 criminal justice system paper eco 550 chapter 6 bus 630 week 1 cmgt 445 managerial issues bus 402 week 5 assignment cja 474 barton paper com 100 intro to human communication devry busn 379 econ 545 project 2 cousin edgar cmgt 445 implementation plan purchase generic requip 1 mg online maxalt 5 mg order overnight buy real requip 1 mg cheap prednisone 20 mg online no prescription buy orlistat 120 mg over the counter cheapest seroquel 200 100 50 300 mg buy generic lisinopril 5 mg online problems with buying finasteride 1 mg without rx prednisone 20 mg cheapest place to order india premarin 0.625 mg buy discounted metformin 500 mg online finasteride 1 mg with no rx principen without rx overnight shipping asacol without prescription or membership buy arcoxia where no prescription benicar arcoxia on line no script order benicar online next day delivery generic benicar tablets buy benicar cost how to get a keflex prescription no rx benicar where to buy principen online order generic cleocin where to buy casodex by cod online pharmacy feldene canadian prescriptions principen keflex cash on delivery buy asacol online canada spe 544 qs lamictal in canada buy benicar paypal without rx can i buy asacol online casodex citrate cycrin from india uop res 351 final exam psy 435 working with employees portfolio assignment qnt 351 mymathlab pos 421 week 4 xacc 280 financial statements exercise prg 421 retail calculator proj 410 planning implementation res 342 final exam version 8 psyc 210 buy premarin without rx order finpecia uk purchase requip without a prescription overnight shipping buy finasteride from usa without a prescription where can i buy requip online without a prescription finasteride ordering without a dr requip for sale buy finpecia online india orlistat online without prescription buy no online rx metformin buy requip without doctor seroquel buy online in stock premarin shipped by cash on delivery online prescription lisinopril online pharmacy cytotec no prescription cheap arimidex uk buy maxalt without a perscription maxalt order overnight shipping buy cytotec without prescription australia acc 290 week 4 problem 4 2a acc 547 week 6 acc 544 justification for an internal control system acc 440 final exam solutions acc 422 disclosure analysis paper acc 561 exercise 20 3 acct 505 project b solution acc 291 week 5 quiz bcom/275 persuasion bsa 310 week 2 acc 202 problem 16 16 hrm 310 final exam answers hca/270 annualizing staff hrm 326 training key areas paper gen 480 critical thinking case study hcs 490 assignment communication paper fin 571 guillermo furniture store analysis inf 220 final paper fin 370 homework hrm 310 hist 405 week 4 quiz hcs 490 demographic paper aids hcs 433 week 3 hcs 325 effective communication paper fincar without a perscription binäre optionen 60 sekunden strategie handeln mit binären optionen optionen handeln für laien cut cialis 20mg viagra india mastercard tetracycline 250 mg capsule precio levitra kamagra shop buy clomid steroid online uk buy viagra in the usa utiliser viagra jeune cialis price in saudi arabia 42 online valtrex no prescription ou acheter viagra sans ordonnance no prescription lisinopril 2.5mg binäre optionen endlich mit gewinn binäre optionen buch binäre optionen für anfänger kann ich in mazedonien mit bdswiss handeln wie fuktioniert trading mit binaeren optionen binäroptionen demokonto deutsch ohne anmeldung binäre optionen richtig widerstandslinien setzen was beduetet dass beim handel mit binäroptionen besteht das risiko dass sie ihre investition verlieren w binäre optionen webinar aufgenommen wie sicher ist anyoption cmgt 410 week 1 project proposal com 225 ub cis 246 devry cis 517 assignment 2 cmgt/430 enterprise security bus 330 final exam eng 221 final project cmgt 530 edu 620 assistive technology eco 203 week 1 quiz eng 225 final film critique comp 122 lab 5 can i buy prednisolone over the counter in spain where can i buy prednisolone uk can you buy prednisone online buy prednisone in usa buy prednisolone liquid buy prednisolone acetate ophthalmic suspension usp 1 can you buy prednisolone over the counter uk where to buy prednisolone in uk want to buy prednisone prednisolone 5mg buy online buy prednisolone online can you buy prednisone over the counter in greece buy prednisolone tablets for cats buy prednisone 10mg buy prednisolone 5mg for cats cheap prednisone for dogs theo 104 biblical worldview essay res 341 entire course psy 101 chapter 9 test rel 134 week 1 studying religion soc 312 ashford sci 220 human nutrition week 3 res 351 final exam answers sci 207 dependence of man on the environment xmgt 216 ethical issues paper uop hrm 531 soc 100 online social networking paper buy Keflex diet pill binäre optionen etoro maxalt delivered overnight orlistat online order online lisinopril purchase finasteride on line no prescription arimidex by mail generic finasteride online arimidex overnight delivery fed ex purchase cheap arimidex cod free fedex buy cheapest requipbuy no prior prescription requip buy cheap online pharmacy premarin purchase maxalt overnight delivery order orlistat no prescription buy maxalt overnight shipping cytotec cheap on online arimidex tabletten requip buy legal buy finpecia online purchase premarin online what is lisinopril arimidex rezept cytotec purchase without perscripotion buy prednisone cheap without perscription where to buy seroquel by cod uk arimidex cheap cs 270 stanford hcs 440 health care spending paper psy 355 week 3 paper bcom 275 week 1 individual assignment it 205 week 7 checkpoint com 225 quizlet com 537 monmouth road jackson nj 08527 pos 110 week 5 checkpoint soc 100 exam 2 quizlet mgt 418 week 3 acc 290 week 5 quiz acc 421 final exam prg 211 final hum 176 week 7 news media hrm 593 week 5 acc 201 homework mgt 435 week 3 quiz xcom 285 week 2 checkpoint acc 349 week 5 dqs ntc 362 week 2 riordan fin 370 help ldr 531 week 2 knowledge check mgt 230 university of phoenix eco 372 final exam answers free psy 310 history of psychology edu 673 week 1 assignment pol 215 week 5 mgt 230 project mgt411 assignment solution 1 cja 474 organizational effectiveness psy 435 week 5 team assignment psy 390 piaget chart iscom 471 syllabus bcom 275 week 6 phil 201 exam 4 acc 557 level submission) edu 620 technology changes everything acc 291 article analysis eco 203 math 533 devry prg 211 week 4 individual assignment ashford bus 644 week 1 dq 2 benefits of forecasting coll 148 week 3 personal profile summary oi 361 week 4 assignment mental models and mindsets paper eth 376 full course (accounting ethics and professional regulations) ashford mgt 460 week 5 dq 1 leading organization change eco 372 week 5 dq 1 pos 409 week 2 individual dice simulation ashford mgt 330 week 5 dq 1 steps of control ashford crj 303 week 4 the world of prison staff gm588 course project ashford mha 601 entire course (principles of health care administration) cis 207 cis207 week 5 assignment new system proposal and presentation hrm 587 week 2 course project managing organizational change part 2 acc 310 week 1 dq1 eco 372 entire course: phoenix university: new updated course generic cytotec 200 mcg online no prescription metformin 500 mg without a rx buy metformin 500 mg online without prescription buy non prescription drugs generic cytotec 200 mcg canadian generic seroquel 200 100 50 300 mg no prescription buy finpecia 1 mg 200mcg buy prednisone 20 mg pills no prescription buy cheapest premarin next day delivery on requip saturday buy seroquel toronto maxalt no script overnight finasteride shipped over night without a prescription buy 850 mg metformin misoprostol buy online buy cytotec over the counter where can i purchase maxalt without a prescription seroquel rezept requip and valacyclovir finasteride without a prescription canadian where to buy lisinopril by cod acc 460 week 1 bio 101 exam 1 quizlet acc 491 individual assignment week 3 acc 423 week 5 acc 491 week 4 team assignment ba 225 acc 340 week 5 team assignment acct 505 managerial accounting acct 553 week 3 homework es acc 202 unlv aed 201 week 6 appendix c bio 101 unit 1 test mgt 448 individual globalization questionnaire mkt 421 final exam study guide mkt 421 course syllabus math 533 week 6 netw 230 adapter driver mm522 final exam phl 323 evaluation of a business code of ethics ldr 531 final exam questions math 157 week 7 discussion question mktg 522 week 2 math 221 statistics for decision making phi 103 week 5 assignment mgt 307 week 1 mat 126 week 5 quiz mth 213 mgt/567 ethics and social responsibility final exam mgt 360 net ladder mkt 421 week 5 final exam ops hc 571 design matrix where can i buy furosemide 40 mg how to buy viagra legally where can i buy cialis in uk buy cialis cebu purchase viagra now buy viagra online overnight shipping where can i buy xenical online in the uk can you buy viagra in koh samui cheap viagra europe us mail order viagra do i need a prescription to buy propecia best way to buy viagra finasteride off patent seroquel reviews sleep cheap alternative to seroquel buy premarin cream uk average cost of seroquel can maxalt get you high buy prednisone tablets generic seroquel cost walmart buy premarin cream seroquel off label usage how to get proscar instead of finasteride going off premarin should i get on finasteride seroquel 200 mg cost cost metformin buy generic seroquel online finpecia cipla online where to buy orlistat in canada babyrevian shop and rental iscom 471 week 2 fin 571 best mix of capital case hsm 220 personal profile plan fin 375 financial management in the small business law 531 final exam answers free inf 103 computer literacy hsm 220 week 2 hcs 405 week 4 ratio computation hcs 405 week 3 fin 419 international finance paper hcs 446 week 3 team summary hcs 465 week 2 assignment it/205 management of information systems hca 270 cost classifications part ii come fare soldi col trading online opzioni binarie con chiusura anticipata comp sci 220 sito opzioni binarie ioption opinioni un esempio di opzioni binarie importo minimo su opzioni binarie optionweb opzione binarie plus 500 su iphone 5 60 secondi opzione call hsm 220 budget matrix hcs 341 training and development paper hcs 451 quality management assessment jrn 412 iscom 471 week 3 fin 515 week 4 quiz hsm 220 week 6 fin 534 financial management book law 531 business law final examination cis321 week 7 fin 534 textbook generic orlistat no prescription buy cytotec next day delivery no perscription maxalt lisinopril 10 mg no prescription lisinopril purchase cheap online premarin wholesale prednisone buy arimidex pay cod cytotec available at health department conto demo su opzioni binarie best forex indicators binary options signals come guadagnare sui derivati forum opzione binarie perdite opzioni binarie simulatore operazioni binarie demo opzioni binarie 60 secondi opzioniu binarie opzioni binarie in italiano e in euro iq optiom iqoption postepay fineco trading con opzioni binarie eng 125 introduction to literature busn 319 devry busn 412 devry engl 227 purdue eng 102 week 1 assignment eng/135 week 3 edu 305 week 5 cja 304 effective communication in criminal justice settings engl 227 week 1 assignment scenario cja 304 barriers effective communication paper eco 316 syllabus busi 561 liberty university engl 112 cmgt 445 managerial issues edl 515 price of arimidex in pakistan cytotechnology review metformin order online buy prednisone dogs seroquel xr reviews anxiety where to buy lisinopril prescription abbreviation for nitroglycerin seroquel reviews depression arimidex pct for sale maxalt purchase cytotechnology online course metformin price in malaysia seroquel prescription discounts cheap prednisone cgd 218 week 2 assignment cja 334 research proposal eco 372 weekly reflection week 3 forex tester commissioni trading opzioni binatiw tenpo si puo guadagnare con le opzioni binarie iq option truffa o no forex signals free come caricare denaro finto su iq option iqoption com reqp 1&reqr nzcdyaevlae5pv52mj opzioni binarie senza registrazione la migliore piattaforma per opzioni binarie opzione binaria sezione strategia guadagnare con internet coaching opzioni binarie gratis segnali opzioni binarie a pagamento azioni binarie recensioni milano oggi opzioni binarie short phd thesis pregnant women on cocaine mla thesis title page computing msc dissertation essays of racism writing personal essays how to come up with a dissertation title phd thesis on agile techniques how to write a college application essay 6 paragraph avatrade test beste zeit für handel mit optionen binär broker www binaere optionen de 365tradind de option time 70 rendite binã re optionen www bdswiss com unterschied zwischen cfds und binär optionen optionyard lizenz bdswiss kom binary option best ea bot forum stiftung warentest binäre optionen oliver pott binã re optionen gd artlands etrading gmbh automatisch binäre optionen handeln www binäre optionen edu 639 24 option conto demo option plus demo per investire in operazioni binarie come operare nel tocca non tocca opzioni binarie opzioni binarie con rendimento utiluzzo robot opzioni binarie bus 402 week 5 assignment busi 330 marketing core econ 545 final eco 561 quiz 3 eco 550 market model patterns of change busi 330 exam eng 230 university of kentucky busi 330 what is tenormin buy keflex pill arcoxia no script required express delivery purchase tenormin cod next day delivery is it legal to buy asacol online non prescription desogen cleocin overnight delivery order generic cleocin online no prescription buy lamictal no rx buy atarax diet pills opzioni binarie sito italiano buy benicar without a percsription generic revia cost how to get cycrin online no prescription in 2.5 days buy principen in united states online arcoxia with no prescription arcoxia no doctor prescription buy keflex canada generic arcoxia fedex fare trader di materiali https it opteck com piattaforma web grafici a candela per opzioni binarie where can i purchase maxalt no rx buy cheap requip under without rx hrm 531 week 2 knowledge check hcs 325 week 3 assignment iscom 383 final hcs 531 week 6 his 301 week 2 quiz hrm/531 human capital management law 531 contract creation and management assignment eth 125 appendix b answers hcs 440 syllabus hcs 320 nursing home administrator hrm 587 communicating the change law 421 week 4 acc 561 tootsie roll acc 421 week 2 reflection bsa 310 general it system inventory bis 220 reflection summary acc 201 acc 301 uky acc 548 week 4 powerpoint acct 346 tab 2 apol 104 week 7 quiz bus 303 ashford acc 547 9mm ant 101 syllabus acct 553 week 2 assignment bio 101 midterm quizlet acc 561 week 6 assignment acc 290 study guide acc 202 msu ant 101 week 4 biol 101 quiz 13 acc 556 bis 220 acc 423 week 4 bis 220 final exam answers free bshs 312 week 2 acc 202 help room acc 290 studentoffortune comm 315 queens cheap arimidex by money order buy cheapest metformin and metformin buy prednisone online with no perscription buy cheap finasteride without a prescription prednisone online purchase cheap lisinopril usa order finpecia maxalt without a perscription order no online rx requip lisinopril purchased online without prescription finpecia costco price buy premarin online cod buy lisinopril without a credit card where to purchase generic premarin online without a prescription buy metformin usa buy finpecia 1mg india buy premarin amex online without prescription buy online metformin orlistat online no prescription and overnight prednisone buy online no prescription buy premarin without doctor buy premarin online cod orlistat overnight without prescription where to buy lisinopril by cod finasteride without a prescription canadian requip and valacyclovir seroquel rezept buy cytotec over the counter where can i purchase maxalt without a prescription maxalt no script overnight finasteride shipped over night without a prescription fin 444 final his 125 week 7 appendix b hcs 341 week 5 powerpoint hcs 320 week 4 flowchart his 103 week 1 quiz fi515 week 7 assignment fin 419 week 3 team assignment inf 103 week 5 research project iscom 383 presentation hca 240 cancer patient information sheet checkpoint fin 370 my finance lab fin 366 final exam stock pair halbautomatisch binäre optionen handeln misoprostol buy online buy cheapest premarin how to order lamictal ordering atarax online purchase cycrin online without script i need to order lamictal without a prescription buying cycrin without a script revia overdose buy benicar no prescription needed buy tenormin cod i want to order casodex without a prescription keller acct 505 final exam fin 366 week 5 quotazioni index call option trader di opzioni binarie hcs 457 terminology worksheet hrm 531 performance management plan it 205 week 1 hca 421 week 2 hca 250 week 8 approaches to decision making eth 316 week 3 dq law 421 entire course gen 480 university of phoenix do i need a prescription to buy valtrex can you get pregnant while taking valtrex bactrim ds for sale can you buy atarax over the counter uk buy benicar online cheap lamictal success bipolar disorder can keflex affect milk supply getting pregnant after desogen feldene buy buy motilium australia generic bactrim ds cost how long for benicar to wear off do i need a prescription for bactrim cost of atarax at walmart hero online ataraxia items benicar cash price feldene gel without prescription fin 366 uol ethc 446 5w hca 240 appendix f fin 415 week 3 fin 515 midterm exam hrm 300 week 3 chart hius 221 quiz 1 fin 370 exam hca 270 week 9 final presentation acc 564 quiz 3 mgt 426 final exam phi 103 ashford university psy 450 intelligence testing article analysis bis 220 reflection summary eng 102 final exam econ 545 project 1 situation a sec 280 week 5 mkt 498 final exam mgt 307 final exam answers com 530 5 7 1 authentication required hca 270 how are costs tied to staffing psy 360 visual ambiguity presentation acc 491 exam nur 492 process improvement and change project presentation eth/125 historical worksheet law 531 week 2 assignment it 244 week 3 checkpoint broker demo trading conviene trading on line per principianti autoazioni binarie opzioni binarie primi passi trading opzioni binarie come funziona opzioni binarie siti sicuri optione binary zulutrade binary options opzioni binarie versamento minimo 50 euro auto binary system ip option autppzioni binarie com www iqoptio com ordering fincar online without a precription canadian pharmacy fincar finpecia free shipping fincar 200mg tablets express shipping order fincar online consultation fincar no rx order fincar overnight fincar fedex how to order fincar online without a prescription fincar order overnight problems with buying fincar without rx fincar online no prescription and overnight cheap fincar no prescription order fincar order fincar online i need to order isotretinoin without presciption and order it cod finpecia cipla buy onlain buy generic fincar without perscription order fincar no prescription fincar no prescription finpecia>no prescription ordering fincar from canada without a prescription buy genuine fincar in the u.s. buy generic fincar online no prescription quick delivery online pharmacy no prescription fincar non prescription fincar hrm 587 week 4 was sind binären optionen 24 option demokonto fin 366 individual reflection paper fin 403 week 5 hca 250 motivation organizational culture fin 534 homework chapter 12 hcs 440 week 2 team assignment exp 105 personal dimensions education hcs 514 807 it 205 week 6 the contribution of enterprise systems law 421 week 3 discussion questions online consultation for principen order no online rx benicar buying principen lamictal online pharmacy benicar without prescription overnight shipping next day fedex shipping for lamictal arcoxia no prescription overnight uk benicar revia without a prescription shipped overnight express principen generic online casodex bestellen cheap generic keflex no prescription buy online revia 50 mg principen without rx medications how to order arcoxia online without a rx lamictal without prescription medications buy revia no prescription needed buy generic lamictal canada no prescription revia order generic cleocin online no prescription asacol mastercard principen rezept buy cheap generic feldene how to get cleocin tenormin buy online cleocin purchase overnight delivery order viagra online fast where to buy viagra in melbourne over the counter buy furosemide uk where to buy valtrex 500mg cheap off brand viagra hist 405 fin 370 university phoenix furuno fi504 fin 419 week 2 team assignment hca 270 week 7 dq 2 hca 250 change and innovation fin 370 risk analysis fin 515 week 6 hrm 326 week 2 his 145 week 5 hius 221 week 1 hca 421 week 3 assignment order premarin no visa without rx online prescription arimidex buy finasteride overnight shipping purchase finasteride online no membership problems with buying prednisone without rx buy maxalt online order arimidex overnight cheap no perscription maxalt where to buy maxalt no perscription no fees cheap premarin uk buy lisinopril pills order generic premarin buy premarin overnight buy metformin online now buy arimidex in india cytotec generic online how to order a prednisone taper purchase maxalt without a rx online orlistat shortage buy maxalt online pharmacy best place to buy finasteride where to buy lisinopril hctz maxalt for cheap where can i buy cytotec pills where can i buy herbal requip can you buy cytotec over the counter orlistat tablets usa buy metformin extended release prednisone 20 mg purchase maxalt non prescription for next day delivery buy amoxicillin antibiotics online uk buy proscar uk online can you buy cytotec over the counter purchase maxalt cod cash delivery requip from india is it safe buy amoxicillin 500mg uk where to buy metformin 1000 mg maxalt no r x foreign should i buy finasteride online cheap cytotec pills online where to buy maxalt no prescription no fees prednisolone 5mg buy online order maxalt online buy cheap metformin online order finasteride where to buy ampicillin for betta fish buy cheap fluoxetine online buy phenergan elixir online order neurontin cheap overnight at washington can i buy doxycycline over the counter buy zoloft brand online buy amoxicillin order generic zoloft buy doxycycline hyclate 100 mg buy phenergan with codeine where to buy doxycycline in philippines buy zovirax cream canada where to buy doxycycline hyclate can you buy doxycycline in singapore buy ventolin evohaler 100 mcg where to purchase zoloft buy atarax tablets buy ventolin inhaler ebay orlistat in greece buy orlistat buy medicine from cannada orlistat orlistat tablets uk purchase orlistat orlistat 60 mg orlistat usp monograph xenical orlistat 120 mg price generic orlistat 120mg orlistat fast delivery ubat orlistat 120mg where to buy orlistat online cheapest orlistat uk orlistat 60mg cheap orlistat 120mg orlistat online switzerland math 126 ashford university mgt 490 mgt 230 powerpoint mgt 230 final exam week 5 mgt 311 week 4 learning team ops 571 week 1 process design matrix and summary mgmt 410 week 4 quiz math 117 week 4 quiz answers math 110 problems phil 201 concordia university mha 601 principles of healthcare administration phl 458 famous creative thinkers presentation hrm 498 week 3 team assignment law 531 contract creation and management assignment hca 459 hcs 483 week 4 it project implementation failures fin 571 final exam hcs 451 week 5 eth 125 week 5 historical report on race hca 240 week 4 blood disorders eth 557 week 6 jrn 412 law 531 week 2 hcs 341 human resource management presentation hca 430 week 3 assignment eth 316 week 3 discussion questions gen 499 general education capstone fin 571 week 6 wiley assignment hca 270 health care finance hcs 449 case study analysis presentation fin 486 week 5 eth 125 week 2 stereotypes and prejudice worksheet hcs 587 papers fin 419 week 3 eth 125 week 4 appendix d hrm 531 week 5 reflection law 421 quiz ldr 531 week 4 mgt 311 section i change management plan mkt 421 blue ocean strategy paper mgt 420 discussion questions phil 201 quizlet phil 201 test 1 mkt 571 marketing environment simulation and summary mgmt 520 week 6 discussion ops 571 study guide psy 340 week 5 phi 208 week 3 quiz hrm 498 entire course hcs 440 week 1 assignment it 205 week 8 assignment eco/561 final examination study guide eco 561 final exam questions math 110 test bis 320 week 5 final exam ph 220 labs xacc 280 the accounting equation psy 101 2nd gdb solution busn 319 course project psy 410 anxiety matrix trading di opzioni binarie forum option trading strategies binary option strategies investire in prodotti derivati simulare azioni binarie gistar srl trading azionibinarie fare soldi con il riciclo conti correnti trading binario montaldo come guadagnare i soldi con il trading binario lista broker per opzioni binarie demo trading 212 opzioni binarie sistema binario diborsa iquit binary options titantrade it sw opzioni binarie instant forex pay cod for prednisone 20 mg without prescription purchasing orlistat 120 mg cheap premarin 0.625 mg no prescription finasteride 1 mg prescription cost buy orlistat 120 mg online made in america lisinopril 5 mg order overnight can i get metformin 500 mg without a prescription? overnight no prescription premarin 0.625 mg finpecia 1 mg order on line order maxalt 5 mg no prescription buy generic maxalt 5 mg online no prescription quick delivery canada orlistat 120 mg no prescription finasteride 1 mg uk medication finasteride 1 mg finasteride 1 mg buy online trading con candele giapponesi avatrade rinnovo conto demo opzioni binarie si perde molto trading binario cosa guadagnano borsa binaria robot opzioni binarie 1 euro video pubblicità bdswiss trading opzioni binarie opzioni binarie e carta paypal robot opzioni binarie 60 secondi binary options affiliate opzionistrategiebinarie autopzionibinarie paypal trading online sul petrolio segnali opzioni fare soldi con il riciclo https iqoption com ru iq optiond autopzionibinarie demo gratuito www currency rate com punto opzionibinarie todos los brokers opciones binarias regulados opzioni binary info su binari optyon desktop di bdswiss com prova azzioni binarie iq option regolamentato da digital options programma di prova per opzioni binarie corso opzionibinarie broker opzioni vanilla trading online conti demo forex binario online iq ooptions opzioni binarie scommessa minima fm financial trader opzioni 24 opzioni binarie stockpair boss capital binary options le opzioni www winner option it buy maxalt without a prescription online canadian generic cytotec no prescription arimidex overnight no consult where to purchase generic finasteride online without a rx where to buy cheap maxalt no perscription buy prednisone without a prescription purchase maxalt prescription online buy maxalt amex online buy generic orlistat online prednisone to buy in canada buy premarin with a visa buy cytotec no prescription buy arimidex online without prescription maxalt overnight fed ex no perscription fedex arimidex overnight without a prescription https affiliate iqoption com new options numeri binari metodo fibonacci opzioni binarie com è il sito opzioni binarie recensioni autopzione binarie com optionrally review vivir de opciones binarias auto opzioni binadie recensione iq option miglior sito binary online optionavigator it strategia opzioni binarie 60 secondi collaudata importo minimo opzioni binarie aiuti con iq option trading binario deposito basso forum optioni binary https iqoption com ref 1282523 come funziona l opzione binaria trader binario demo opzioni binarie il sole 24 ore iq trading programmi per opzioni binarie binäre optionen am ipad online trading demo konto poweroption bdswiss app android halb automatische software binäre optionen seriöse literatur über binäre optionen trading al ribasso opzioni binarie traslider deposito 50 euro opzioni binarie mini conti 24h trading sito sistema binario trading on line borsa opzioni binarie intesa sanpaolo migliori broker di opzioni binarie a 1 euro guida trading opzioni binarie forex opzioni binarie scommesse binary option trading with our money binäre optionen lukrativ operazione binarie buone o no trading binario come funziona trading binario broker account demo opzioni binarie demo q10 robot per opzioni binarie gratis binaries com trading online soldi virtuali opzioni binarie bufale custon writing com law school application essay best berkeley phd thesis eecs hofstra admissions essay dna rna and protein synthesis essay phd thesis engineering writing a resume for high school students essays on nature seo content writing services civil war essays college application essay pay rules help writing a paper in apa format social anxiety disorder essay outline high quality writing bettina love dissertation exxon valdez essay diwali without crackers essay university of florida mae non thesis masters defending a doctoral dissertation dissertation protection consentement mariage dissertation office university of chicago dissertation argumentative philosophie master thesis event marketing master thesis neural networks discussion dissertation writing nyu cs masters thesis online professional resume writing services sydney dissertation editing services abortion debate essay acheter viagra en belgique pink viagra cialis ankara cheapest cialis no prescription target google viagra order cheap générique viagra soft ordering flagyl online in the us 30 mg dose lexapro healthy man viagra pills bienfait viagra strattera 25 mg cost geld mit binären optionen verdienen bdswiss strategien binäre optionen broker paypal optionen handeln demo konto optionyard erfahrung poweroption binäre optionen währungen binäre optionen leiter binäre optionen endlich mit gewinn wie sie mit binären optionen endlich gewinne machen incl ehrlicher brokertests teil 1 binärer handel erfahrungen 24option agb trading on line in internet negoziazione opzioni binarie 7 giorni su 7 iqopyion soldi gratis spiegazione grafico a candela opzioni binarie trading 24 online optione binarie wwww iqoptions optionibinarie auto binari trading demo options traduci bank opzioni binarie bis155 final exam answers acc 561 exercise 22 1 bsa 375 week 2 individual assignment bibl 104 bible dictionary project old testament acc/291 version 2 acc 497 financial statements paper part i bcom 275 final exam questions biol 101 quiz 3 4 bibl 104 quiz 5 answers acc 423 weekly reflection acc 291 week 2 individual assignment acc 291 week 5 huffman trucking bio 101 organism physiology paper acc 291 final exam part 5 art 101 zpo get valtrex online cita previa medico canarias online hero online ataraxia items anafranil where to buy buy desogen online buy vermox ireland arcoxia online where to get vermox how to not get diarrhea on augmentin vermox rezeptfrei online bestellen buy generic valtrex without prescription valtrex cost 2013 patient reviews for lamictal comprar augmentin online cost of bactrim at walgreens order ventolin hfa online cheap arcoxia prospect valtrex discount card can you get a yeast infection from taking valtrex acc section 306 bsop 588 course project acc 421 syllabus acc 561 super bakery bio 101 online course acc 306 final paper bis 220 brick and mortar binär broker test 24option erfahrungsbericht 60 sekunden optionen demo stockpair betrug anyoption meinung geld mit binären optionen verdienen was ist binäre optionen demokonto bdswiss psych 560 jeans proj586 final psy 101 learning sci 241 assignment dietary supplements report xacc 280 appendix c jane kent sci 100 university of phoenix res/351 learning team reflection soc 101 online quiz res 351 pos 110 syllabus psy/250 final exam res 342 hypothesis identification article analysis binäre optionen mindesteinzahlung 10 binary options best strategy bdswiss binäre optionen tipps phd thesis international marketing are there essays that cant be detected of plagiarism purchase a dissertation vue literature review for masters thesis proposal primary homework help romans mosaic movie review sites racial discrimination essay essay of man pros and cons of homework for kids where to buy essay online buy here pay here business plan pay someone to do assignment how to write a conclusion for dissertation proposal writing my essay best dissertation writing service uk history georgetown university phd thesis vermox cost target pharmacy valtrex valtrex for sale priligy buy online usa costco pharmacy valtrex revia cost cita previa online itv valencia vara de quart cheap valtrex no prescription atarax prospecto keflex cost australia where can i buy valtrex over the counter lowest price benicar arcoxia price in malaysia revia buy online atarax uyku getirir mi valtrex official site can you get high from atarax valtrex getting pregnant how to buy bactrim online is it illegal to order zoloft online buy zovirax topical ointment where to buy bactrim ds online buy augmentin over the counter buy ventolin pills online cheap augmentin can i buy ventolin at asda order celebrex over the counter cheapest generic avodart buy proventil hfa inhaler buy generic amoxil online celebrex for cheap buy ssri dapoxetine acc 542 full course (all assignments) accounting information systems demo above below opzioni binarie no deposit bonus forex opzioni binarie investire 50 euro www bdswuiss com opzioni binarie giocare gratis senza deposito opinioni su opzioni binaries forex vendita online opzioni binarie strategia opzioni binarie demo gratis senza registrazione ogni 60 sec 24option com è affidabile deposito minimo iqoption come prevedere i mercati delle opzioni binarie trading online bper fare trading online demo option navigator iq option come si usa trading con pochi euro optioni binarie ddemo out out opzioni binarie moncler opzioni call migliore piattaforma opzioni binarie 2014 cheap tenormin 25 orlistat sandoz buy orlistat online from canada how to wean yourself off seroquel xr where can i buy generic finasteride seroquel for ocd reviews finasteride online singapore how long does it take to come off seroquel what is the cost of seroquel without insurance does seroquel 300 mg get you high buy orlistat 120mg malaysia what does arimidex cost cheapest price for finasteride maxalt lingua online kaufen buy finasteride online uk cheap seroquel users review cytotec tablet price finasteride online bestellen law 531 newcorp scenarios legal brief hcs 465 week 2 individual assignment inf 103 week 1 discussion 2 fin 419 week 4 individual assignment hcs 587 theoretical change models hca 270 week 4 sci 230 week 8 dq 1 psy 480 entire course math 221 lab 6 uop nur 440 acc 492 week 4 team assignment bcom 275 week 3 article rebuttal theo 104 final exam mgt 311 week 5 communication plan english 230 devry bus 475 integrated business topics syllabus bus 520 assignment 3 psyc 210 quiz 2 liberty university sci 220 university phoenix mgt 431 week 1 bus 520 leadership and organizational behavior final exam hcs 320 week 4 assignment acc 201 practice tests acc 497 exercise 1 17 acct 346 tab 2 bus 155 bsa 385 week 3 individual assignment bis 245 week 1 quiz acct 324 hughes biol 101 sjsu acc 557 week 6 bio 100 week 3 appendix f acc 291 final exam acc 421 week 5 bande di bollinger online strategie funzionanti opzioni binarie forex binario costi full quote netdania autopzionibinarie ho perso tutto giocare in borsa opzioni binarie notizie trading tempo reale opzioni binarie con robot indicatore macd opzioni binarie la società click 4 surveys che promuove le opzioni binarie organizza truffe oppure c è da fidarsi del suo operato iq option bonus code no depozit operazioni binarie complemento a 1 eng 125 final paper rough draft busn 412 in the news english 101 reflective essay cpmgt 300 project management bus 599 week 2 quiz cja 314 week 3 ece 201 help bus 591 cja/324 ethics in criminal justice cis 170 strayer eco 561 syllabus cis 207 university of phoenix bus 599 strayer university syllabus cja 314 week 5 bus 640 final project buy asacol online cheap asacol retail cost asacol reviews buying asacol from canada where to buy asacol online purchase asacol what is the cost of asacol buy asacol 800mg asacol price usa how to store asacol asacol drug cost order asacol online asacol cost at walmart how to get asacol hd patient savings card asacol prescription assistance program do you have to wean off asacol buy asacol enema asacol prescription savings card asacol discount coupon asacol cost canada how to get asacol patient savings card cheap asacol side psy/103 week 4 oborsa opzioni binarie option bit demo anyoption binary trading opzione binarie plus 500 su iphone 5 60 secondi come investire in derivati guadagnare online opzioni binarie pos 110 civil liberties and civil rights sci 241 week 2 discussion question soc 315 week 2 psy 490 week four quiz sci/230 version 7 psy 310 history of psychology prg 420 week 5 learning team psy 301 final paper qrb 501 week 3 problem set qnt 561 chapter 2 qnt 561 week 5 problem set soc 101 gdb solution spring 2015 sci 241 week 2 discussion question 1 salinas psy 301 final exam pos 110 appendix d qnt 561 business research project part 5 qnt 351 stat lab psy 375 issue analysis worksheet psy 405 psychodynamic theory presentation soc 203 week 4 quiz str 581 week 1 quiz sci 207 environmental footprint uop res 351 final exam answers psy 101 chapter 12 res 351 tutorial psy 310 week 5 powerpoint str 581 week 2 sci 230 week 7 evolution assignment unm engl 120 xcom 285 checkpoint group communication pol 201 exam str 581 syllabus university of phoenix project proposal approval phase cpmgt 300 psyc 210 quiz 2 liberty university psy 405 week 2 personality overview qnt 351 week 1 paper proj592 week 5 assignment problems sci 209 week 1 proj 586 project charter psy 101 chapter 9 is 339 school of community technology hum 176 week 3 gen 200 university of phoenix syllabus hcs 440 week 4 assignment eth 316 week 2 team assignment eth 376 week 5 reflection gt 420 upgrade gbm 380 hcs 490 matrix hcs 451 week 4 dq it 205 week 4 where can i buy finasteride uk buy bactrim for uti donde puedo comprar redustat orlistat buy prednisolone for cats uk requip overnight cod cheap prednisolone tablets buy orlistat arimidex 1 mg non rx cheap requip is it safe to order prednisone online buy cytotec online uk buy prednisolone for cats generic 5mg fincar online can you buy amoxicillin at walgreens buy prednisone for cats online acc 564 assignment 1 biol 101 quiz 8 acc 202 chapter 1 acc 561 week 5 wiley plus answers bsa 375 week 3 individual acc 557 homework bshs 352 opzioni binatie fin troppo semplici opzioni su azioni opzioni binarie economiche acc 205 week 3 bshs 373 accounting short answer questions acc 380 acc 306 acc 455 week 2 opzioni binarie per tutti su plus 500 ci sono le opzioni binarie fair binary options linkedin demo account opzioni binarie www iqotion sistemi binari trading siti opzioni binarie con demo guadagnare soldi online http auto binary it piattaforma demo per opzioni iqoption trading da 1 euro opzioni iso alfa trading regulated options freizeitrucksack fair trade come funziona il trading on line demo trading con le opzioni binarie iq option pagano broker per per iscriversi fare trading binari prezzi forex coibendaggio mercato azionario binary options reviews of asacol asacol hd patient reviews can asacol get you high buy asacol without prescription asacol buy problems with buying fincar without rx fincar with out a prescription fincar in canada fincar ordering order fincar no prescription isotretinoin generic no prescription fincar without prescription buy generic fincar without perscription order fincar online consultation fincar express online order fincar fincar for sale without prescription get fincar without prescription fincar 5 mg without a prescription gen 200 university of phoenix syllabus law 421 final exam answers it 244 physical security policy hius 221 week 7 study guide hca 250 syllabus hcs 320 week 1 communication opinion paper fin 370 caledonia products integrative problem it 244 week 7 access control policy binary matrix agenzie opzioni binarie hcs 325 week 3 assignment hca 250 hcs 457 week 1 article review it 244 week 9 final project fin 515 homework week 1 hca 250 appendix e hcs 577 week 3 its 320 hcs 457 week 2 fin 515 week 1 problem set inf 336 week 2 assignment fin 370 cash budget iscom 383 stroker hum 105 matrix iscom 305 final exam fin 515 week 7 homework str 581 psy 405 personality analysis res 342 final rel 133 week 3 cost asacol hcs 325 week 4 motivational methods hsm 220 week 8 checkpoint hrm 300 week 3 individual assignment auto opzioni binarie cosa sono sito per indici mercato iq option bdswiss opzioni binarie recensioni forum trader analisi forex tempo reale indici transazioni binarie cosa è il trading binario binary option 60 sec 10 euro strategie di trading binario law 531 the legal system and adr analysis www iqoptions opzionj binarie no touch alto rendimento buy amoxicillin for dogs uk how to buy finasteride finasteride online buy seroquel 200 mg order maxalt cash on delivery seroquel 25 mg tablet where to buy propranolol online seroquel mg side effects buy orlistat 120mg where to buy finasteride where to buy prednisolone for dogs orlistat us seroquel 25 mgs what does requip look like online purchase of cytotec seroquel 200 mg dosage where can i buy prednisolone 5mg theo 104 liberty university qnt 351 week 4 psy 355 arousal behavior stress and effect worksheet pos 110 final project democracy in america str 581 learning team peer evaluation psy 475 week 4 worksheet prg 421 zpo qnt 351 final exam 30 questions with answers pos 110 american civic values checkpoint proj 592 week 6 psy 475 week 3 theo 104 total responsibility psych 570 btv pos 110 defining democracy psy 301 research psy 400 week 3 dq 1 soc 105 week 3 individual hrm 300 week 5 fin 415 final exam answers fin 515 princeton hca 417 technology ethics & society hrm 531 week 1 knowledge check hca 270 time value of money worksheet part ii hca 240 week 6 appendix d ethc 445 devry fin/370 version 7 hum 112 quiz 5 conti forex www binary boom com opzioni binarie la verità 4xp opzioni binarie demo pzioni binarie arduino binary counter broker autorizzati consob it options trading italiano investire pochi soldi binary options pdf iq option regolamentato da trade max iqoption operazioni binarie a 60 secondi option xo https iqoption com it login come fare operazioni binarie opzionibinarie fatto quotidiano come aprire piattaforma opzioni binarie dove giocare con opzioni binarie opzioni binarie recensioni oopzioni binarie 60 secondi strategia opzioni binarie strategie opzioni binarie binary options pro signals www winner option it procedura del trading online segnali opzioni binarie opzioni binarie miglior sito engl 101 syllabus engl 227 week 5 eco 204 week 3 quiz com 225 quizlet cja 484 criminal law foundations evaluation bus 610 week 2 assignment dbm 380 week 4 individual assignment edu/310 taskstream assignment lesson plan eco 100 week 2 quiz easton acc 440 ece 205 final project cja 324 week 3 cis 568 week 5 cis 517 assignment 1 comp 230 week 7 ilab edu 310 lesson plan bus 475 week 3 individual assignment comp 230 week 5 quiz cmgt 430 bus 650 week 5 comp 220 midterm exam bus 370 week 4 assignment com 321 quiz show busn 258 week 2 dbm 380 week 3 individual cte property management next day delivery on requip saturday res 342 week 1 paper where to buy requip online buy metformin weight loss buy finpecia cipla cheapest place to buy requip buy glyburide metformin can i buy prednisone over the counter in spain how to order cytotec online orlistat diet pill where can i buy lisinopril online buy cytotec iloilo buy finpecia online where can i buy finasteride in india seroquel xr 400 mg side effects buy 850 mg metformin generic fincar without a precsriptions maxalt prescription from doctors online buy fluconazole online with a debit card buy pharmacy antabuse waterview online antabuse fluconazole mexico online robaxin and fedex glucophage buy online in stock how to get a proscar prescription online proscar and fedex cheapest online indian pharmacy for cytotec or generic maxalt no rx foreign order maxalt no prescription buy maxalt pill where to buy fluconazole buy fluconazole cod iq 0ption come fare pratica di trading opzioni binarie il minimo da versare sul conto quanto e opzioni binarie spiegate in maniera semplice semplice opzioni bianrie intesa sanpaolo trading training sistema binario lg option trading trading strangle eng 121 week 4 quiz bus 644 week 5 assignment buy strattera online no prescription order prednisone 20 mg no prescription to buy finpecia 1 mg buy orlistat 120 mg finpecia 1 mg buy online without rx buy generic orlistat 120 mg online no prescription quick delivery english king 100 years war eco 561 final bus 630 week 1 cja 454 week 2 eco 316 u of t eco 372 international trade speech eng 225 week 5 assignment english 100 sentences edu 620 week 4 assignment comm 315 quizlet cja 364 xl cja 454 edu 305 key theories of development bus 401 week 5 bus 311 week 1 discussion com 226 cmis 141 syllabus bus 402 week 2 assignment buy cialis online forum phenergan 12.5 mg suppositories allegra d online pharmacy walmart levitra types of cialis good high quality low cost viagra 50 mg phenergan no prescription viagra over the counter walgreens levitra 10 costo cialis 5 mg témoignage du viagra mgt 557 final exam math 117 appendix c polynomials answers ldr 531 university of phoenix ops hc 571 limits ops hc 571 the learning curve theory nr 305 welding wire phi 445 zpo mgt 418 entrepreneurial advisor math 117 week 3 checkpoint mkt 421 supply chain paper phl 458 week 1 assignment math 157 nova mgt 498 final mkt 421 week 1 phl 458 week 4 paper hca 250 week 9 capstone checkpoint law 531 final exam with answers paper hcs 483 week 3 hcs 587 organizational change plan hum/176 media and american culture syllabus law 531 university of phoenix hcs 325 week 3 dq 1 hius 221 reading quiz 1 his 103 midterm hcs 405 week 4 learning team assignment hcs 325 week 2 effective communication paper i need a philosophy paper written for me writing book reviews for money website analysis essay richard hunt masters thesis cathrine himberg dissertation ap biology homework help app for homework first order logic homework solution assistance in writing a paper should parents help high school students with homework auditing homework help term paper on english apa style term papers essay on teenage pregnancy to write an essay professional paraphrase essay interactive essay writing dissertation about teaching and learning how to write an essay of application write my assignment australia bahareh azizi dissertation ops hc 571 the project management email mgt 311 quiz mgt 445 week 4 individual ops 571 design a flowchart for a process mgt 420 exam 1 mgt 498 week 5 paper ops 571 quiz oi 361 week 2 team assignment math 221 final exam ldr 531 week 2 msu psy 280 syllabus ntc 362 entire course mgt 311 test ldr 531 week 3 leadership style buy requip online order generic prednisone online no prescription buy metformin online with a debit card arimidex orderd online without prescription finasteride non prescription finpecia online prescription purchace prednisone online orlistat cheap online metformin 850 mg buy maxalt without prescription where to purchase prednisone oral cheap cytotec without prescriptions in usa finasteride online consultation overnight metformin no doctors prescription where to buy cheap finasteride no prescription order premarin without rx needed finasteride online buy saturday delivery buy premarin australia cytotec purchase canada buy 2 mg requip buy maxalt online without a perscription xenical without prescription no rx requip buy lisinopril drugs canada finasteride no prescription what is metformin buy cytotec next day delivery maxalt in canada buy lisinopril without rx purchase finasteride online no membership overnight shipping buying prednisone with no rx can i get orlistat without a prescription? orlistat cost psy 301 emotional intelligence sci 220 psych 515 critical issue analysis proj410 case study 3 res 351 week 5 powerpoint pos 110 week 4 checkpoint voting in america soc 320 week 2 assignment qrb 501 week 6 final exam prg 421 team assignment sci 241 understanding food labels xmgt 216 final powerpoint pos 110 appendix d xmgt 216 week 1 dq 2 psy 340 sensory system presentation psy 250 week 5 iqoption truffa esercizi trading real time exchange rates opzioni binarie simulatore recensioni su autopzionibinarie iq option otc https www iq option com commissioni trading bot opzioni binarie top option opzioni binarie trend opzioni binarie miglior bonus segnali binari free commenti forex data verità su opzioni binarie iqopitions devisen live autopzioni binarie tutorial opzioni binarie giochi gratuiti auto robot per operazione binarie https drive google com folderview id 0b rojuk_bjh2duzgmnfwbl9gdvu&usp sharing analisi opzioni binarie dei broker in tempo reale e gratis quando apre la borsa oro siti di borsa online dmax opzioni binarie mgt 401 gdb math 115 umich mgt 498 week 1 discussion questions math 126 waterloo phi 103 quiz mgt 411 week 5 mth 209 week 5 mkt 500 strayer syllabus mat 116 week 7 dq 1 phil 201 concordia outline iq option wiki optionibinarie60 robot opzioni binarie recensioni corso opzioni binarie gratis trade opzioni binarie come togliere liscrizione dall iqoption iforex italia imparare opzioni binarie binary option paypal forex opzioni binarie certezza rischio option prime lp option opzione binarie fineco trading demo forex trading game uk options la borsa facile opinioni opzioni binarie sito serio e sicuro iqoption consigli binary trading ebook trading gratis fare soldi col trading online sistema binario forex binary bot software automatico opzioni binarie online trading standard bank ametista binario forex new tips pepperstone binary options iq option modalita di rimborso wztrader trading gratis come vincere sempre con le opzioni binarie trading giovanni romano demo gratis forum opzioni binarie 24options exchange money online opzioni binarie optionfair quanto e il deposito minimo cose il trding binario trade navigator come funzuona iqoption comù grafici a candela per opzioni binarie allenarsi al training binario in italiano robot opzioni binarie demo gratis senza deposito iq option in italiano