Patents in the Field

 

The term “patent exhaustion” does not refer to the feeling you get when an IP lawyer talks for 3 hours about invalidity for lack of obviousness. No, this is the patent law concept that the first authorized, unrestricted sale of a patented item ends, or “exhausts,” the patent-holder’s right to ongoing control of that item, leaving the buyer free to use or resell the patented item without restriction. For example, if you buy a patented mouse-trap from the patent owner, you can resell that mouse-trap to your neighbour without fear of infringing the patent. 

This concept was recently tested in the case of Monsanto Co. v. Vernon Hugh Bowman (PDF) No. 10-1068 (Fed. Cir. Sept. 21, 2011) related to Monsanto’s patented “Roundup Ready” seeds. A farmer planted a first crop from Monsanto seeds, under license, and he did not save any of those seeds for replanting, in accordance with the license. The farmer then bought “commodity seeds” from a local grain elevator. These seeds are a mixture of regular seeds and seeds from “Roundup Ready” plants. Not that you can tell by looking at them. I don’t believe Monsanto has developed a method of displaying the Roundup patent numbers on the seeds themselves. He planted a second crop from these “commodity seeds”. He then saved some of the seeds from this second crop grown from the “commodity seeds”.

Monsanto sued, claiming the second crop and the saved seeds infringed on its patent, because its patented technology existed somewhere in that crop. The farmer defended by claiming the defence of “patent exhaustion” - that any patent rights in the second crop of seeds were exhausted, and further use or sale of those seeds would not infringe Monsanto’s patent. The Court rejected this defence, reasoning that by planting the commodity seeds containing the “Roundup Ready” patented technology, he created an infringing article (i.e. the plant grown from the next generation of seeds).  This replication of the patented article constituted an infringement, which was not excused by the “patent exhaustion” doctrine.  This is because there was no unrestricted sale, since the use of the seeds by the farmer was conditioned upon obtaining a license from Monsanto. The court did not review the question of whether someone else (someone who is not subject to Monsanto’s license agreement) would benefit from the “patent exhaustion” doctrine if they grew and collected “commodity seeds”.

Related Reading: Patent Exhaustion Does Not Bar Claims Against Later Generations of Self-Replicating Technology LES Article.  

Related Reading: Intellectual Property & Agriculture: Obvious Inventions

Calgary - 07:00 MST

No comments yet. Be the first.

Leave a reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.


Deprecated: Function set_magic_quotes_runtime() is deprecated in /home/rstobbe/ipblog.ca/wp-content/themes/rstobbe/style.php on line 118

Deprecated: Function set_magic_quotes_runtime() is deprecated in /home/rstobbe/ipblog.ca/wp-content/themes/rstobbe/style.php on line 125

Deprecated: Function set_magic_quotes_runtime() is deprecated in /home/rstobbe/ipblog.ca/wp-content/themes/rstobbe/style.php on line 118

Deprecated: Function set_magic_quotes_runtime() is deprecated in /home/rstobbe/ipblog.ca/wp-content/themes/rstobbe/style.php on line 125
where can i purchase zithromax online purchase Buspar no visa online without prescription medikament Alli uk buy Lisinopril buy Lisinopril legally Metformin uk Metformin from india cheapest place to buy Metformin buy Metformin free consultation order generic Metformin Metformin drug purchase Buspar without prescription to ship overnight buy Maxalt for women buying Maxalt online without prescription generic Maxalt without a precsriptions Maxalt generic names buy cheap metformin without prescription Premarin mexico buy Metformin without a credit card buy Metformin no rx Premarin drug order cheap overnight Premarin buy Premarin online with no prescription Maxalt no prescription overnight delivery buy Maxalt next day delivery Premarin ordered without a perscription online Maxalt purchase Alli online no prescription Alli buy Alli purchase online prescription metformin without online Metformin order buy Metformin no prescription low cost Finpecia purchase canada buy Finpecia store no rx finpecia with fedex buy finpecia next day delivery