Copyright Infringement & Licensing Pitfalls

The case of Leuthold v. Canadian Broadcasting Corporation , 2012 FC 748 (CanLII) illustrates several common licensing pitfalls.

In this case, a photojournalist who was on the scene in New York City on September 11, 2001, licensed a number of still photographs to the CBC for use in a documentary about the 9/11 attacks.  The photos were included in 2 versions of the documentary, and the documentary was aired a number of times betwen 2002 and 2004. The question was whether all of the broadcasts were within the scope of the licenses granted by Leuthold as the copyright owner. More than one license was granted through various emails, faxes and license agreements between the parties.

Taking this case as a cautionary tale, here some of the common pitfalls to watch for:

  • The specific works must be identified - which specific photos or copyright-protected works are included in the license?
  • Who are the licensees? - in this case network affliliates did broadcast the works, and CBC was liable for the infringing broadcasts of these regional affiliates or stations.
  • The scope of a broadcast license should be clear on whether the rights include one or more broadcasts, in one or more time-zones, and by one or more affiliates. In this case, there was considerable debate about whether CBC Newsworld was included in the license. The court decided that it was included, by looking at the surrounding circumstances, though the terms of the license were not entirely clear.
  • The scope of any license should be clear on whether the license is exclusive or non-exclusive.
  • Consider whether the license should state the geographic or territorial scope. In this case, the license referred to Canadian broadcast rights, but CBC Newsworld international also broadcasts into the US and internationally.
  • Consider the impact of follow-up emails and correspondence which might be used as a de facto license, or to interpret the meaning of the license.

Ultimately, the court found that the CBC had infringed copyright in the photographs in six broadcasts which were not covered by the licenses. Damages of US$19,000 were awarded.

For copyright licenses, get advice from the Field Law Intellectual Property & Technology Group.

Calgary - 07:00 MST

No comments yet. Be the first.

Leave a reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.


Deprecated: Function set_magic_quotes_runtime() is deprecated in /home/rstobbe/ipblog.ca/wp-content/themes/rstobbe/style.php on line 118

Deprecated: Function set_magic_quotes_runtime() is deprecated in /home/rstobbe/ipblog.ca/wp-content/themes/rstobbe/style.php on line 125
buy seroquel in canada buy generic seroquel australia buy seroquel mastercard seroquel online purchase buy cheap seroquel buy seroquel online uk buy seroquel american express can i get seroquel without a prescription? seroquel online without prescription seroquel 50mg tablets can you buy seroquel online seroquel buy online generic seroquel without a precsriptions buy Requip with american express purchase Tamoxifen prescription Requip buy brand Cytotec buy Tamoxifen without doctor Maxalt drug furosemide order tamoxifen without rx Tamoxifen purchase without prescription Order Finasteride online without a prescription arimidex 1 mg without prescription arimidex 1 mg order online buy accutane online australia accutane generic sale arimidex 1 mg without prescription accutane generic buy order accutane online no prescription order accutane canada buy accutane american express order arimidex uk i need to order Arimidex without a prescription Cytotec oral how to buy cytotec online without a rx generic Seroquel without prescription canada order buy Cytotec online Cytotec mexico buy cod Cytotec where can i buy Cytotec online without a prescription buy online Cytotec Cytotec purchase Cytotec without rx needed buying Cytotec over the counter Cytotec non rx fedex overnight free order Cytotec overnight buy cytotec in the uk order Cytotec overnight buy Cytotec shipped cod how to order Cytotec online without a rx buy Cytotec cheap online Cytotec online prescription buy Accutane australia no prescription where to buy Requip without a prescription buy generic Accutane uk purchase Cytotec visa without prescription order Tamoxifen Cytotec overnight buy Cytotec amex online without prescription buy cheap generic Finpecia online canada pharmacy no prescription buy Furosemide with no prescription can you buy Clomiphene online Finasteride online without prescription purchase Cytotec over the counter cod overnight Cytotec overnight cod buy generic Cytotec buy Clomiphene 50mg buy Isotretinoin canada pharmacy Metformin buy Cytotec discount uk Maxalt generic Finpecia 1mg canada Arimidex generic online generic Accutane without prescription where to buy Seroquel online purchase Furosemide where can i buy Arimidex over the counter buy cheap Requip on line Finpecia online sale without prescription