Cloud Computing Law: Balancing Privacy and Investigation

-

Megaupload Ltd. is alleged to have disseminated copyright protected movies and music and US prosecutors now have the task of gaining access to the company’s servers in a bid to prove their case. In the fascinating Megaupload saga, a Canadian court has been asked to decide what to do with 32 servers belonging to Megaupload which are located in Canada. The servers are packed with information - “100 laptops” worth of data according to the judgement - and the court was asked by the US government to deliver that data to American prosecutors who are pursuing charges against Megaupload for criminal infringement of copyright, conspiracy to infringe copyright, money laundering and racketeering.

In last week’s decision, Canada (United States of America) v. Equinix Inc.  , 2013 ONSC 193, the court denied this request, indicating that the massive volume of data meant that the scope of the investigation should be narrowed to just that information that is the target of the search, rather than the entire contents of the data trove. However, the judge did not deny that the evidence should be delivered. Evidence to implicate Megaupload likely is contained within those servers, and it is only a matter of time and negotiation to determine the scope of the search, rather than an absolute denial of the request. “Given the undisputed conclusion” the judge wrote, ”…that there were reasonable grounds to believe that evidence of the offences would be located on the servers in my view the appropriate balance of the state interest in gathering evidence and privacy interests in information can be struck by an order that the servers be brought before the court …so that the court can make an order refining what is to be sent.”

From a cloud computing law perspective, this case raises several important points:

  • Canadian courts will order seizure and search of cloud-computing servers - just like they will with any piece of evidence in Canada - pursuant to a request from US authorities in the course of a criminal investigation;
  • Privacy interests will be balanced by the court, since the law is developing a sense of when individuals have an expectation of privacy in the contents of computers or servers;
  • However, that privacy right is not absolute, but it will be balanced with the interests of governments to conduct investigations.

We can expect another decision to be released before long, where the contents of the servers are indeed delivered to US prosecutors, with some conditions or limitations as to the scope of the search.

Calgary - 07:00 MST

No comments yet. Be the first.

Leave a reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.


Deprecated: Function set_magic_quotes_runtime() is deprecated in /home/rstobbe/ipblog.ca/wp-content/themes/rstobbe/style.php on line 118

Deprecated: Function set_magic_quotes_runtime() is deprecated in /home/rstobbe/ipblog.ca/wp-content/themes/rstobbe/style.php on line 125

Deprecated: Function set_magic_quotes_runtime() is deprecated in /home/rstobbe/ipblog.ca/wp-content/themes/rstobbe/style.php on line 118

Deprecated: Function set_magic_quotes_runtime() is deprecated in /home/rstobbe/ipblog.ca/wp-content/themes/rstobbe/style.php on line 125
buy seroquel in canada buy generic seroquel australia buy seroquel mastercard seroquel online purchase buy cheap seroquel buy seroquel online uk buy seroquel american express can i get seroquel without a prescription? seroquel online without prescription seroquel 50mg tablets can you buy seroquel online seroquel buy online generic seroquel without a precsriptions buy Requip with american express purchase Tamoxifen prescription Requip buy brand Cytotec buy Tamoxifen without doctor Maxalt drug furosemide order tamoxifen without rx Tamoxifen purchase without prescription Order Finasteride online without a prescription cheap Requip online no prescription order Requip uk buy Requip over the counter buy Arimidex usa Requip generic no prescription Requip for sale without prescription Arimidex on line Arimidex in usa i need to order Arimidex without a prescription Arimidex order overnight generic Arimidex canada buy Requip store generic Requip online how to order Requip online without a prescription buy Requip store where can i buy Requip buy generic Arimidex 1mg buy Requip store buy Requip 0,5mg tablets Requip buy cheap buy Arimidex no prescription buy requip 0.5mg uk order keflex uk buy atarax canada online atarax order online buy keflex online uk tenormin online without a prescription buy revia with visa where can i get revia without a prescription tenormin without a rx buy tenormin cheap Cytotec oral how to buy cytotec online without a rx generic Seroquel without prescription canada order buy Cytotec online Cytotec mexico buy cod Cytotec where can i buy Cytotec online without a prescription buy online Cytotec Cytotec purchase Cytotec without rx needed buying Cytotec over the counter Cytotec non rx fedex overnight free order Cytotec overnight buy cytotec in the uk order Cytotec overnight buy Cytotec shipped cod how to order Cytotec online without a rx buy Cytotec cheap online buy Requip uk can you buy Clomiphene online Finasteride online without prescription purchase Cytotec over the counter cod overnight Cytotec overnight cod buy generic Cytotec buy Clomiphene 50mg buy Isotretinoin canada pharmacy Metformin buy Cytotec discount uk Maxalt generic Finpecia 1mg canada Arimidex generic online generic Accutane without prescription where to buy Seroquel online purchase Furosemide where can i buy Arimidex over the counter buy cheap Requip on line Finpecia online sale without prescription