Social Media Law (Part 3: Defamation)

The use of social means to engage in defamation is nothing new. Indeed, defamation requires the very social element of publication. Social media - Facebook pages or posts, tweets, blogs and online comments - merely make defamation easier and more pervasive.

Canadian courts have struggled to balance the interests of free speech with the interests of individuals who wish to challenge and find redress for defamatory statements. A recent Ontario case has framed the issue as follows:

     “There are few things more cowardly and insidious than an anonymous blogger who posts spiteful and defamatory comments about reputable member of the public and then hides behind the electronic curtain provided by the Internet. The Defendant confuses freedom of speech with freedom of defamation. There are, undoubtedly, legitimate anonymous Internet posts: persons critical of autocratic or repressive regimes, for example, or legitimate whistleblowers. The Defendant is not one of those people. The law will afford his posts all the protection that they deserve, which is to say none.”  Manson v. John Doe , 2013 ONSC 628 (CanLII),

The test laid out by the Supreme Court of Canada (Grant v. Torstar Corp., 2009 SCC 61 (CanLII)) is as follows: In order to establish a claim for defamation a plaintiff must establish that:

a)   the impugned words are defamatory, in the sense that they would tend to lower the plaintiff’s reputation in the eyes of a reasonable person;

b)   the words in fact refer to the plaintiff; and

c)   the words were published, i.e., that they were communicated to at least one person other than the plaintiff.

In Manson, the court ordered the defendant to pay damages of $100,000 plus aggravated damages of $50,000 and costs. However, the defenant remains anonymous.

Another recent decision in Baglow v. Smith, 2012 ONCA 407 (CanLII), hints at the court’s willingness to permit parties to engage in a heated online political debate, without crossing the line of defamation. In that case, the court observed: “Commentators engaging in the cut and thrust of political discourse in the internet blogosphere can be fervent, if not florid, in the expression of their views.” In the lower court, the statements made in this “cut and thrust” were determined not to constitute defamation. However, on appeal, the court decided the matter was suitable for a full trial and overturned the lower court findings. This is one case to watch.

Related Reading: ipblog’s Defamation Archive

Calgary - 07:00 MST 

No comments yet. Be the first.

Leave a reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.


Deprecated: Function set_magic_quotes_runtime() is deprecated in /home/rstobbe/ipblog.ca/wp-content/themes/rstobbe/style.php on line 118

Deprecated: Function set_magic_quotes_runtime() is deprecated in /home/rstobbe/ipblog.ca/wp-content/themes/rstobbe/style.php on line 125
Casodex without prescription mexico purchase Benicar pay pal online without rx can i get Revia without rx order Revia pay pal online without rx order Zovirax without a prescription overnight shipping buy prescription Vantin online order Arcoxia online overnight shipping buy Cycrin in england Buy Benicar without a prescription buy Desogen doctor prescription Revia over the counter buy Cycrin online without a prescription where can i get Tenormin Benicar effects buy 90 mg arcoxia Online Zovirax buy vantin without rx from us pharmacy Cleocin order Zovirax online cheap buy Atarax overnight delivery buy Principen no scams Cycrin no prescription to buy buy Casodex no prescription cod to buy Keflex online purchase Lamictal Revia without prescriptions in usa order lamictal overnight cheap where to purchase generic atarax online without a prescription where to buy cheap casodex no prescription buy benicar without a percsription uk lamictal generic safety order keflex casodex overnight online vantin no prescription to buy asacol prescription from s online atarax 100 mg cytotec purchase without prescription buy cheap generic vantin online canada pharmacy no prescription generic 20mg benicar online how to get prescription of lamictal buy vantin in uk how to get keflex without zovirax usa buy cheap desogen with dr. prescription feldene without script purchasing benicar canadian zovirax diet pills without a prescription purchase cycrin pay pal online without prescription buy desogen online overnight buy cheap zovirax online tenormin without rx revia in canada how to buy asacol online without rx buy vantin tablets without prescription buy atarax amex online without rx purchase cheap online principen zovirax with out a prescription where to buy cheap zovirax no prescription feldene available at health department desogen purchased online without prescription keflex precio buy keflex c o d buy benicar doctor prescription order desogen amex online without prescription buy online desogen without rx zovirax apotheke buy vantin no rx wholesale zovirax cheap lamictal 100mg generic asacol 400 mg buy zovirax online overnight arcoxia ordering generic benicar no prescription i want a zovirax prescription lamictal ordering without a dr casodex no rx canadian prescriptions keflex keflex with no prescription and delivered over night revia online online us pharmacy zovirax buy revia epharmacist tenormin without prescriptions in usa keflex online consultation overnight purchase revia online no membership overnight shipping buy revia in england order benicar on line buy tenormin online without script canadian vantin diet pills without a prescription buy atarax on line amex buy tenormin overnight delivery buy vantin overnight order Finpecia buy Finpecia online no prescription uk where to buy Finpecia can i get Finpecia without a prescription? Finpecia purchase without prescription Finpecia in usa cheap Finpecia online no prescription buy finpecia store generic Finpecia no prescription buy Finpecia cheap cheap premarin premarin 0.625mg price order premarin buy premarin canada premarin no prescription 0.625 mg premarin buy premarin 0.625mg cheap generic premarin premarin price australia buy premarin for dogs how to buy premarin buy premarin uk premarin canada prices generic premarin no prescription order premarin premarin buy buy Maxalt drugs Maxalt online prescription buy Maxalt us how to buy arimidex arimidex 1mg side effects order arimidex overnight arimidex purchase overnight delivery order arimidex online no prescription buy generic arimidex uk buy keflex epharmacist buy atarax cod next day delivery buy arcoxia doctor prescription revia 50mg fedex keflex without priscription buy next day keflex benicar with no presciption atarax purchase without prescription buy revia with american express buy vantin online 200 mg no prescription buy lamictal in united states online atarax side effects purchase asacol online no membership overnight shipping no prescription needed feldene principen with no prescriptions buy vantin online 200 mg no prescription Maxalt apotheke buy Maxalt epharmacist buy Maxalt legally Maxalt online no prescription buy Maxalt online us pharmacy order Maxalt no rx Maxalt buy Maxalt buy Maxalt no prescription uk buy Maxalt online purchase Maxalt buy Maxalt in england Maxalt overnight cod ordering maxalt online buy Maxalt cash on delivery Maxalt cheap mexican uk buy Maxalt Maxalt rezept buying Maxalt online discount Maxalt buy Maxalt visa no prescription Maxalt purchase cheap online Maxalt buy Maxalt american express Maxalt by mail buy Maxalt online us pharmacy buy Maxalt online now non rx cheap Maxalt purchase Maxalt online buy maxalt mastercard Maxalt prices Maxalt online prescription Maxalt tablets Maxalt prices Maxalt fedex shipping Maxalt 10mg is it legal to buy Arimidex online Arimidex tablets 1 mg no prescription australia buy online Arimidex 1 mg Arimidex rx cheap best place order Arimidex where to buy Arimidex Arimidex online australia buy Revia buy revia without a percsription order rx free tenormin canadian pharmacy no prescription asacol order cycrin 10 mg without prescription purchase asacol online no membership order buy arcoxia online buy vantin without a rx buy casodex without a prescription to ship overnight ordering benicar over the counter generic vantin uk online revia purchase purchase revia online without prescription non presciption revia cheapest place to buy revia buy revia without a perscription non prescription cheap revia order no online rx revia buy revia no visa without rx problems with buying revia without rx uk order revia Keflex without script purchase Atarax visa without prescription order Atarax without rx needed Keflex available canada buy Keflex diet pill Tenormin fedex cytotec 100 mg without prescription where to buy Premarin online prednisolone online uk Premarin 0.625mg what is it used for buy requip from canada is requip a prescription drug mail order requip Premarin purchase online cost of Premarin canada buy cheap Premarin online prednisolone online uk buy requip 1mg buy requip online usa order requip canada cheap requip online how to buy requip online ordering zovirax buy discount feldene principen without prescription medications where can i purchase lamictal no rx buy cheap asacol without a prescription purchasing vantin online without prescription buy cheap generic arcoxia where to purchase generic revia online without a prescription buying atarax online without prescription online pharmacy Maxalt purchase maxalt without prescription to ship overnight buy Maxalt diet pills buy genuine Maxalt online buy pharmacy Maxalt waterview buy Maxalt Maxalt bestellen Rizatriptan Maxalt buy Maxalt usa buy Maxalt on line cycrin shipped c.o.d. purchase cleocin no visa without prescription buy cleocin tablets canadian pharmacy no prescription atarax cheap cleocin no prescription pharmacy keflex no prescrption lamictal online buy saturday delivery buy vantin overnight delivery can i get vantin without rx purchase principen amex online without rx revia effects buy asacol on line buy cheapest casodex buy revia online uk buy vantin overnight delivery zovirax without dr vantin with no rx buy 1 mg Arimidex uk cheap Arimidex buy Arimidex 1mg canada buy Arimidex 1 mg online can i get Arimidex without rx buy 1mg Arimidex requip online for dogs requip buy where can i buy requip online cost of requip australia purchase Premarin online