Social Media & Non-Competition Clauses

-

In our earlier post (Are Non-Competition Restrictions Enforceable?), we reviewed “restrictive covenants” - these are clauses under which employees are bound by restrictions such as non-competition restrictions, non-solicitation obligations, and other controls on the employee’s behaviour which bind the employee after termination.

In Eagle Professional Resources v. MacMullin, 2013 ONSC 2501, the court considered a dispute between two competitors - Eagle and Maplesoft.

Eagle alleged that its ex-employees took confidential information from Eagle, and began soliciting clients, employees, and contractors of Eagle to work for Maplesoft. The defendant ex-employees argued that they did not use any confidential information to solicit business. They asserted that any contact information that they used was already publicly available through LinkedIn or Facebook accounts.

When reviewing the enforceability of restrictive covenants in the employment context, the court reiterated a three-part test (when in doubt, there is always a handy three-part test ): 

  • Does the employer have a proprietary interest entitled to protection? 
  • Are the temporal and spatial features of the restrictive covenant too broad? (Put another way, are there reasonable limits in time and geographic space?)
  • Is the covenant unenforceable as being against competition generally, as opposed to a more limited covenant against solicitation of former clients?

The court concluded that “there is no evidence from Eagle, other than a very bald assertion, that it had any proprietary interest entitled to protection. According to the Defendants, the information that they learned at Eagle was all publicly available and obtained from such sources as social media websites.” There are a few take-aways from this decision:

  1. When drafting restrictive covenants in the employment context, non-solicitation and confidentiality clauses are more likely to stand up, whereas non-competition clauses are likely to be struck down as unenforceable, as in this case. Make sure to have your agreements reviewed;
  2. If a “confidential customer list” is virtually the same as the employee’s LinkedIn or Facebook contacts, then there will be no proprietary interest to protect, since the information will be publicly visible to anyone.
  3. The court will assume that the employer will lead with its strongest evidence. Compelling evidence of specific cases of solicitation or competition is critical for success in an application by the employer - as the court quipped “Lead with trump or risk losing”. In this case, the evidence was ambiguous or it fell outside the non-competition period.

Calgary - 7:00 MST

No comments yet. Be the first.

Leave a reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

i want to buy prednisone without a perscription order prednisone free next day airprednisone on line Buy accutane with visa where can i purchase synthroid 200 mcg mastercard without a prescription buy finpecia no prescription low cost where to buy finpecia without a prescription where can i purchase zithromax online purchase Buspar no visa online without prescription buy Atarax amex purchase cheap Atarax online buying Cytotec online lisinopril lisinopril buy lisinopril lisinopril buy Metformin from india Metformin side effects buy Lisinopril cheap uk buy Lisinopril buy Lisinopril legally buy finpecia over counter buy finpecia online prednisone no physician prednisone in mexico without a perscription purchase Buspar without prescription to ship overnight where to buy Amitriptyline without a prescription Premarin mexico valtrex generic pharmacy iframe Buy Valtrex from usa without a perscription purchase Maxalt without buy Metformin without a credit card buy Metformin no rx finpecia online pharmacy buy cheap valtrex without prescription free fedex delivery Valacyclovir Amitriptyline from india Premarin drug order cheap overnight Premarin online Maxalt purchase buy cheap generic prednisone online canada pharmacy no prescription buy prednisone oral Metformin online purchase buy Metformin doctor prescription order metformin without prescription to ship overnight where to purchase metformin no prescription no fees metformin order online metformin suppliers buy Metformin in united states online Metformin sale buy Metformin from india finpecia online no rx finpecia with fedex buy finpecia next day delivery purchase Premarin without prescription to ship overnight where buy Premarin